Want to buy or sell something? Check the classifieds
  • The Fedora Lounge is supported in part by commission earning affiliate links sitewide. Please support us by using them. You may learn more here.

What's the holy grail of hat collecting?

jedichase

New in Town
Messages
8
Location
in the swamps of central florida
Hey everybody,

Although I'm new here I've been collecting hats and other antiques for a couple of years now. However, I've never heard of a hat that is etremely hard to find or was made in a very small quantity. Besides original movie hats (Bogarts fedora in Casablanca, or Ford's fedora in Raiders), what is considered the rarest fedora in the world? Thanks for reading and for any info.

Chase K.
 

Rick Blaine

My Mail is Forwarded Here
Messages
3,958
Location
Saskatoon, SK CANADA
Hey jedichase!

Hey everybody,

Although I'm new here I've been collecting hats and other antiques for a couple of years now. However, I've never heard of a hat that is etremely hard to find or was made in a very small quantity. Besides original movie hats (Bogarts fedora in Casablanca, or Ford's fedora in Raiders), what is considered the rarest fedora in the world? Thanks for reading and for any info.

Chase K.

Hiya & welcome to TFL! Glad to see another Cracker. :p

Great & oft axe'd (as is the vernacular, here) question, I think many would agree it would be one of these in a size wearable by modern man. They came w/ the ermine tails of the critters used in the hat, a real BFD of a lid. Others here however have more diverse criteria... what is YOUR Holy Grail, jedichase?
 
Last edited:

DavidJ

One of the Regulars
Messages
190
Location
Norman, Ok
That's the hat that came to my mind, and I could even wear it! I personally don't know my Holy Grail hat, but I'm sure I'll know it when I see it.
 

barrowjh

One Too Many
Messages
1,398
Location
Maryville Tennessee
I think any vintage hat that serendipitously turns out to be a really top-shelf hat AND in pristine condition would add up to a well-pleased collector. This ebay buy cost me just over $100 -
Ninfea3.jpg
Ninfea1.jpg


I sent it off to Optimo for a full refurb and it became the hat in this pic
012308051.jpg

090107005-1.jpg


There was this navy blue (cobalta) borsalino that a lady put on ebay with a $70 BIN:
122108005.jpg

122108001.jpg

This is classic 1930's construction (sweat sewn directly to the felt except for the forehead area, liner sewn to the felt), really a nice hat to own and wear.
JTL provided a seminar on teardrop creasing with it in post #5 in this thread:
http://www.thefedoralounge.com/showthread.php?36304-MONTEAGLE-2009&highlight=monteagle

Neither of those two hats measure up to an ermine beaver 100 Stetson, but they represent a level of quality almost all of us will be well-pleased to acquire and wear. I have a few other examples, but I think these two go a long way towards describing a reasonable 'holy grail' for me.
 

Sam Craig

One Too Many
Messages
1,356
Location
Great Bend, Kansas
Besides original movie hats (Bogarts fedora in Casablanca, or Ford's fedora in Raiders), what is considered the rarest fedora in the world? Thanks for reading and for any info.

Chase K.

Well, Chase, for me it would be the three hats I've been looking for since 1974:

1 Long finish beaver top hat in a medium brown or tan

2 Beaver felt Mexican combrero

and 3, the American equivalent, an original Tom Mix-style western

All three in my size and wearable condition, of course.

I don't really look for them anymore, but I will say, when I was 30 years younger, the search was exciting and I came very close on a couple of them several times.

Of course, I must add, in those days money ... anything over 25 bucks ... was an object.

Today with the Internet, all you need is the cash.

Sam
 

mercuryfelt76

One of the Regulars
Messages
209
Location
London, England
Sam, you're right, I forgot the sky-high beaver top hat. There seem to be a lot of "civil war" collectors who only sell their beaver top hats to American buyers. Besides I want a British one, like Brunel used to wear but I just can't find one in this country. Did the British destroy em all? I suppose we didn't have a celebrated civil war to encourage us to keep em. If anyone owns a 7.5" (or more) high "dandy" top hat in a 7 1/8 UK, preferably British made, I'd be glad to make you an offer...
 

Sam Craig

One Too Many
Messages
1,356
Location
Great Bend, Kansas
I blame the lack of old toppers here directly at the feet of Gene Autrey and "Frosty the Snowman"

There must have been some magic in that old silk hat they found.

Bull

Stinkin' vandal kids ... putting top hats on filthy snowmen

Harrumpfff!

Sam
 

jedichase

New in Town
Messages
8
Location
in the swamps of central florida
Thanks for the welcome. Even though my search for a holy grail hat thread turned nothing up I knew that there had to be one.

My personal holy grail at this point in collecting would be a adventurebuilt raiders in beaver, and for non-fedoras a british colonel's pith helmet.
 

bowlerman

I'll Lock Up
Messages
6,292
Location
South Dakota
I've been fantasizing about Optimo's hats (from afar I like their Oxford and their 47th street), but would probably have to sell all my others in order to afford one!

Otherwise, this one is still kind of my Holy Grail:

p3030421.jpg


It was my grandfather's Stetson fifteen 3X mode edge with amazing colors (to me anyway). He died when I was one year old. My dad currently has it, and wears it himself once in awhile.
 

ShortAndCashed

One of the Regulars
Messages
247
Location
NE Alabama
Mine would be a mint condish silverbelly Stetson Stratoliner. I want one really bad. But, in 7-3/8, they're expensive and hard to find. So, I'll probably find a cheap silverbelly western, and try to convert it. :D
 
Messages
15,228
Location
Somewhere south of crazy
I've been fantasizing about Optimo's hats (from afar I like their Oxford and their 47th street), but would probably have to sell all my others in order to afford one!

Otherwise, this one is still kind of my Holy Grail:

p3030421.jpg


It was my grandfather's Stetson fifteen 3X mode edge with amazing colors (to me anyway). He died when I was one year old. My dad currently has it, and wears it himself once in awhile.
"Uh hey, Dad, do you mind if I borrow the hat?"
 

Forum statistics

Threads
107,023
Messages
3,026,605
Members
52,528
Latest member
Zonko
Top