-
The Fedora Lounge is supported in part by commission earning affiliate links sitewide. Please support us by using them. You may learn more here.
Replacement for Carhartt Chore Coat
- Thread starter Retromoto
- Start date
Pdxgeo
A-List Customer
- Messages
- 318
There is an "army navy" surplus store here in Portland called Andy & Bax. They are carrying "used" (gently it seems) Carhartt chore coats. I have no idea where they get them from but last time I was there they had a great selection of larger sized ones. They had several colors some of which I had never seen before.
As a conclusion to the thread, I ordered a L.C. King "Landon" Barn coat, received it and I'm very pleased. It's USA made, fits perfect for what I wanted which is fall & winter layering, long enough to fit over a T & sweater or a T shirt, long sleeve shirt, and wool vest. It was 13 degrees outside today and I worn it over a LS Bayside cotton T and light-medium weight "Lee Valley" Ireland merino wool sweater. I was perfectly comfortable although there was minimal wind and plenty of sunshine outside. Coat is IMO closer to a Chore Coat design and cut, has a blanket lining and is cut perfectly for layering. L.C. King's site was dead on for measurements, quick to ship and kept me posted every stop the coat made on the way to me. I looked at everything I could find to replace my Carhartt although there seems to be a trend on close fitting items, clothing that imo appears too snug, almost undersized for the purpose and form. I can't recommend L.C. King enough, very straight forward company, quick to ship, great communication and above all, a great USA product. 
G.
G.
Last edited:
AeroFan_07
I'll Lock Up
- Messages
- 5,344
- Location
- Iowa
Great find!! I've really enjoyed all my LC King jeans!
Lord Flashheart
A-List Customer
- Messages
- 398
- Location
- Victoria, Australia
Hi Retromoto,
I’m on the point of ordering one of these jackets too. Can I ask your measurements and what size you went for? I’m 6’3, 43 chest and they have recommended a Medium tall which seems a bit small for me? Also, how does the colour on the site compare to the jacket in the flesh? Any fit pictures?
Regards
Garry
I’m on the point of ordering one of these jackets too. Can I ask your measurements and what size you went for? I’m 6’3, 43 chest and they have recommended a Medium tall which seems a bit small for me? Also, how does the colour on the site compare to the jacket in the flesh? Any fit pictures?
Regards
Garry
- Messages
- 6,311
- Location
- South of Nashville
@Retromoto, glad you finally found a replacement. It took two years. Thanks for letting us know the resolution.
Garry,
I'm 5'11-1/2" tall, 185lbs, 45" chest, 34" waist. 33" sleeve. Compared LCK's online measurements to my other coats and ordered a "Large". As mentioned I wanted something long enough to cover a wool vest or sweater and loose enough to layer with. The large would be too large for me if I wore it solo over a T shirt. My guess is the size they recommended for you is very close as they seem to run a bit large, I typically wear a XL for layering so was hesitant but it worked out well. The color in person is imo a bit darker brown than the pictured item, less golden. I don't have pics right now, I've had issues posting pics on this forum. The forum says it's too large a file although I've never had issues on other sites
Good luck,
G.
Yep, it's been couple years. I did make CC purchase last year although sent it back. I also dropped
20lbs and was able to sub another coat for layering in place until I found something more appropriate.
I guess I'm a little picky, coat had to be, right length, cut for layering, sleeves lined with something smooth and made in USA. I'm patient though and it worked out in the end.
Ernest P Shackleton
One Too Many
- Messages
- 1,220
- Location
- Midwest
I was considering picking up a Tough Duck 2137 Chore Jacket. Are they still made in Canada? Anyone with a review and opinion?
AeroFan_07
I'll Lock Up
- Messages
- 5,344
- Location
- Iowa
The Tough Duck is cheaper in US than Canada, but at those prices, I would suspect they are not made in Canada.
https://toughduck.com/product/duck-chore-jacket/
If you want US-made, but hand and If you have $350 for such a jacket, this would be a great work jacket - I'd size for layers myself.
https://redcloudscollective.com/products/the-belmont-jacket-field-tan?
Or this for a little more coverage:
https://redcloudscollective.com/collections/jackets-2023/products/waxed-canvas-jacket-havana
https://toughduck.com/product/duck-chore-jacket/
If you want US-made, but hand and If you have $350 for such a jacket, this would be a great work jacket - I'd size for layers myself.
https://redcloudscollective.com/products/the-belmont-jacket-field-tan?
Or this for a little more coverage:
https://redcloudscollective.com/collections/jackets-2023/products/waxed-canvas-jacket-havana
Ernest P Shackleton
One Too Many
- Messages
- 1,220
- Location
- Midwest
Thanks for the links. 3Xs more than I'm interested in spending, but I appreciate the exposure. So many brands.
