Want to buy or sell something? Check the classifieds
  • The Fedora Lounge is supported in part by commission earning affiliate links sitewide. Please support us by using them. You may learn more here.

When is close enough, good enough? What would you do?

Coriu

One Too Many
Messages
1,154
Location
Virginia
Not sure this will be of any help, but here goes. Would say the same to anyone collecting jackets, especially someone with some gray on their head. Why not think toward the future and buy a bit on the bigger side to allow for "growth" as you age? Even if your weight doesn't change, gravity does interesting things to our bodies as we age that can radically change fit. There are so many things that can cause us to put on weight as we grow older...many out of our control, ie health issues. It would be a shame to have a "perfect" collection of jackets today become unwearable in one fell swoop because one cut things so close from a fit perspective.
 
Messages
17,133
Location
Chicago
Not sure if I should even go there but I will…
What about the back length? Now it looks great in the photos you posted but I thought I remembered you saying that a back length that short meant the jacket was not going to hang around long.
Despite the tape it hits me right in the sweet spot, so that’s a non factor. Back length only hurts me when there’s no front drop. Even 1” front drop helps compensate a shorter back length, at least in most cases.
 
Messages
17,133
Location
Chicago
Not sure this will be of any help, but here goes. Would say the same to anyone collecting jackets, especially someone with some gray on their head. Why not think toward the future and buy a bit on the bigger side to allow for "growth" as you age? Even if your weight doesn't change, gravity does interesting things to our bodies as we age that can radically change fit. There are so many things that can cause us to put on weight as we grow older...many out of our control, ie health issues. It would be a shame to have a "perfect" collection of jackets today become unwearable in one fell swoop because one cut things so close from a fit perspective.
Fair point but if anything, I suspect I’ll lose weight. Even three weeks out of the gym cost me nearly 10lbs. I’m very strict with my diet and I do work hard to avoid much fluctuation in weight. I do hear what you are saying. I don’t spec jackets for tomorrow though and this one was a very low impact purchase. I just don’t think the extra $400 I’ll pay for a size up will pay much dividend. I’m just not convinced. I feel like I’ll be on the other side asking myself if the 42” is too big.
 

Hobbes1

A-List Customer
Messages
382
Keep this oxford and cancel/change the order. If t his fit is comfortable, keep ot as it looks great! You can live with it and always order a larger size at a later date.
 

Coriu

One Too Many
Messages
1,154
Location
Virginia
Fair point but if anything, I suspect I’ll lose weight. Even three weeks out of the gym cost me nearly 10lbs. I’m very strict with my diet and I do work hard to avoid much fluctuation in weight. I do hear what you are saying. I don’t spec jackets for tomorrow though and this one was a very low impact purchase. I just don’t think the extra $400 I’ll pay for a size up will pay much dividend. I’m just not convinced. I feel like I’ll be on the other side asking myself if the 42” is too big.

Well, maybe something to consider for the future then, especially with a jacket(s) you know you'll keep forever. I swore I would always have six pack abs...then life humbled me with some serious health issues. If there was one positive, it cured me of my perfectionism LOL Good luck with the jackets and decision!
 

El Marro

My Mail is Forwarded Here
Messages
3,484
Location
California
Despite the tape it hits me right in the sweet spot, so that’s a non factor. Back length only hurts me when there’s no front drop. Even 1” front drop helps compensate a shorter back length, at least in most cases.
Right on. Just goes to show numbers only tell you so much. I think it looks very good, and I think you’re right that the front drop makes the difference because otherwise it would be riding up and showing belt buckle.
 

MrProper

My Mail is Forwarded Here
Messages
3,873
Location
Europe
Not sure this will be of any help, but here goes. Would say the same to anyone collecting jackets, especially someone with some gray on their head. Why not think toward the future and buy a bit on the bigger side to allow for "growth" as you age? Even if your weight doesn't change, gravity does interesting things to our bodies as we age that can radically change fit. There are so many things that can cause us to put on weight as we grow older...many out of our control, ie health issues. It would be a shame to have a "perfect" collection of jackets today become unwearable in one fell swoop because one cut things so close from a fit perspective.

Such a massive change in the body is often self-inflicted, regardless of age. If a disease causes it, you probably have other problems than not fitting leather jackets.
I would look at it optimistically: Leather jackets that fit perfectly now will motivate you to fit tomorrow.
And if they don't, that's an excellent excuse to buy new jackets.lol
 

MrProper

My Mail is Forwarded Here
Messages
3,873
Location
Europe
Back length only hurts me when there’s no front drop. Even 1” front drop helps compensate a shorter back length, at least in most cases.

This is exactly what I have found out in the meantime. The back length is only meaningful in conjunction with the front drop.
With my measurements, the back length + front drop = 69 cm and then the chances are good that it looks good.
 

navetsea

I'll Lock Up
Messages
6,711
Location
East Java
this size fit you well, it doesn't even look tight like some jackets you wore. maybe if you order different color it would make sense to have one a size bigger for more relaxed look vs a trim look, but that works for normal folks out there who own 2 or 3 leather jackets, not for someone who already have so many other stellar options like you.
 

MrProper

My Mail is Forwarded Here
Messages
3,873
Location
Europe
How does it work with custom jackets at Vanson?
Can I just specify the dimensions of the jacket, as I do at 5*? Select leather and go?
 
Messages
17,133
Location
Chicago
How does it work with custom jackets at Vanson?
Can I just specify the dimensions of the jacket, as I do at 5*? Select leather and go?
I’m not entirely sure. I’m emailing her the jacket I want, which they made, for Logan’s closet. This Halfbelt:
426E14F4-8059-46D8-9EC4-5B580FBD12FD.jpeg
CB72854C-90B3-475E-99C4-8D701DA26AB1.jpeg

They don’t have this leather, nor do they have any octogan. I asked about brown and they do have some, so I’ll see what that looks like or I’ll do it comp weight.
 

MrProper

My Mail is Forwarded Here
Messages
3,873
Location
Europe
I’m not entirely sure. I’m emailing her the jacket I want, which they made, for Logan’s closet. This Halfbelt:
View attachment 369959 View attachment 369960
They don’t have this leather, nor do they have any octogan. I asked about brown and they do have some, so I’ll see what that looks like or I’ll do it comp weight.
Many thanks.
Then I am curious.
A Vanson I would like, but only with my dimensions. Otherwise they do not fit. Despite customs duty in the EU, the price should be within reason.
 
Messages
10,263
I’m not entirely sure. I’m emailing her the jacket I want, which they made, for Logan’s closet. This Halfbelt:
View attachment 369959 View attachment 369960
They don’t have this leather, nor do they have any octogan. I asked about brown and they do have some, so I’ll see what that looks like or I’ll do it comp weight.

What about the TB leather offerings for the HB? Can Vanson do any of those cool browns without bringing TB into it?
 

El Marro

My Mail is Forwarded Here
Messages
3,484
Location
California
Many thanks.
Then I am curious.
A Vanson I would like, but only with my dimensions. Otherwise they do not fit. Despite customs duty in the EU, the price should be within reason.
I don’t think they will allow you the free range offered by 5 Star but if there is a model that you like they may allow you to tweak the dimensions a bit.
 

Forum statistics

Threads
107,199
Messages
3,030,648
Members
52,669
Latest member
Pablosstuff
Top