Poll: Button or snaps on your suspenders?

Mysterious Mose · Dec 22, 2009

Tomasso said:
Are you referring to employing a shank when attaching a button?

Yes! Shanks! Thanks!
Now could you tell me what you call this buttoning arrangement?:

avedwards · Dec 22, 2009

If I wore braces I'd wear them with buttons. As it is, my build allows me to achieve the same effect with braces, belts or waist adjusters. I think either is acceptable if done with trousers designed to be worn that way (belt with belt loops and braces with brace buttons).

However, I recently saw a clothing store selling braces which were convertable - they had both snaps and the leather loops used for buttons. I personally think the indecisiveness that conveys makes it score even lower than snaps.

Mysterious Mose · Dec 22, 2009

mothfighter said:
Hi Mose,

Guess this is the Dutch version of the BB.
My contribution to the Mose-eum!
(I'll Take It with me the next time we meet; in case you don't
have it in the collection already, which I doubt!!)

Great Suit BTW (The German one?)

Cheers, Kaar

Cool!!! Is that the Old Town cords?

Lokar · Dec 22, 2009

avedwards said:
However, I recently saw a clothing store selling braces which were convertable - they had both snaps and the leather loops used for buttons. I personally think the indecisiveness that conveys makes it score even lower than snaps.

My first pair of button braces were those. I couldn't find any button braces anywhere in Sweden, so I got a cheap pair of M&S button&clip braces shipped over. First thing I did was to throw away the clips, though.

dhermann1 · Dec 22, 2009

If the clip ons lead somebody to the higher realms of button suspenders, then I will make an exception for that. Magnanimity is my middle name.

mothfighter · Dec 23, 2009

Mysterious Mose said:
Cool!!! Is that the Old Town cords?

Nope, The Yellow cord is of the ol' upstairs "Travel" armchair.
Old Town's hardly visible in the back, with the RL Fairisle!
(Slowly getting somewhere)

RobStC · Dec 23, 2009

Buttons!!!

Chances are, if a pair of trousers don't have the necessary buttons (leaving aside accidentally missing ones), then they will most likely have belt loops. Unless in an extreme emergency, it is simply unforgivable:rage: to wear braces on trousers that were designed to be supported by a belt and fitted with belt loops. It is just wrong and UGLY.....:rage: Plus the trousers will not be suitably cut.

This effectively rules out the use of clip on braces in most situations.

If a pair of trousers has neither belt loops nor buttons for attaching the braces, then they will either have proper waist adjusters or be so perfectly fitting (ie bespoke) that they will not require any form of external help. If you have a pair of trousers that are so nicely cut, then the last thing you want to do is attach nasty, shiny clips to them :eusa_doh: .....

Do I make my point sufficiently clear?

Long live buttons! Down with clip on braces!!

Mysterious Mose · Dec 24, 2009

Anybody?[huh]

Mysterious Mose said:
Yes! Shanks! Thanks!
Now could you tell me what you call this buttoning arrangement?:

Torpedo · Dec 24, 2009

Buttons. If the trousers do not come with them, I will install them. I will not remove the belt loops.
I have one pair of clip suspenders, which I use only if I have to use trousers which have not yet their suspender buttons sewn; and only if worn with a waistcoat, so efectively hiding the clips.

John in Covina · Dec 24, 2009

I get all excited over pants with suspender buttons already in place.

Torpedo · Dec 24, 2009

John in Covina said:
I get all excited over pants with suspender buttons already in place.

:arated:

Tomasso · Dec 25, 2009

Mysterious Mose said:
Now could you tell me what you call this buttoning arrangement?:

They are termed links, as in: "I prefer that my morning coat have a link closure rather than a button closure."

BTW, suspender/brace buttons aren't generally attached using a shank. Actually, they're the only buttons on a suit that don't require a shank, due to their convex back.

wintergreen · Dec 25, 2009

I voted for buttons and clips...... I do wear button braces with my clothes but i see nothing wrong with clip ons.
If you have buttons you should wear traditional braces..if you have clip on braces, wear then does it matter? enjoy

Jauntyone · Dec 25, 2009

Buttons are ideal, but it can be difficult sewing them on as they must be sewed to the inner waistband without the stitches showing on the outer band. Also, modern pants aren't really made to be worn with braces--the inner band can be pulled up and out which is not very good!
Looking thru old magazines, I've seen many ads for clip-on braces, so I imagine that they were very popular in the golden age:

Besides, if you wear a vest or leave your jacket on, who'll ever know?

Mysterious Mose · Dec 25, 2009

Tomasso said:
They are termed links, as in: "I prefer that my morning coat have a link closure rather than a button closure."

BTW, suspender/brace buttons aren't generally attached using a shank. Actually, they're the only buttons on a suit that don't require a shank, due to their convex back.

Hello Tomasso,

Links, I never knew that.

I think it looks great.
And yes, all the suspenders buttons on my trousers are convex,I checked. Again, I never knew. The few I put on myself weren't and when I sewed them on too tight the tabs curled up around the buttons. I like those bachelor buttons.

Thanks for your troubles, M.M.

Highlander · Dec 25, 2009

Absolutely buttons. I'd never wear clip on suspenders...

John in Covina · Dec 26, 2009

Clip-on suspenders are not the best choice by far, but they may be considered an inexpensive introduction to using suspenders. Much like a first fedora may have been a wool one, as one's education in these matters would lead to a furfelt next. So one may graduate up from clip on to button type.

davestlouis · Dec 26, 2009

I have brace buttons in every pair of wool trousers I own, and have never worn braces. In theory I think they should be very comfortable, and allow one to wear trousers so they aren't tight at the waist. In reality, I'd feel silly wearing them. I have horrible memories of high school dances in the 80s, when people wore those silly clip-on braces, trying to look cool...yuck.

Related question: don't braces cause a lot of wear on your shirt? What material are they normally made of? Wouldn't they have a potential to discolor the shirt?

jamespowers · Mar 11, 2010

Doran said:
Sewing a button is truly the easiest thing imaginable.

It is as easy as tying shoes.

Learning to read is much harder.

If you can spell your name, you can sew a button.

If I did not know how to sew a button, I certainly wouldn't admit it in front of anyone.

You can learn how to do it in less than 30 seconds.

Yep, you walk into the tailor's shop leave the pants and when you come back they are done. Super easy.

MisterCairo · Mar 11, 2010

Buttons pour moi. Clips on suspenders/braces is like a clip on a tie - just not done, ol' chap!

Poll: Button or snaps on your suspenders?

Buttons or snaps on your suspenders?

Buttons

Snaps

Practically Family

Call Me a Cab

Practically Family

A-List Customer

I'll Lock Up

New in Town

A-List Customer

Practically Family

One Too Many

One Too Many

Incurably Addicted

New in Town

Practically Family

Practically Family

A-List Customer

Practically Family

I'll Lock Up

Similar threads

Log in

Forum statistics