Want to buy or sell something? Check the classifieds
  • The Fedora Lounge is supported in part by commission earning affiliate links sitewide. Please support us by using them. You may learn more here.

The Holmes Fedora

Yeps

Call Me a Cab
Messages
2,456
Location
Philly
Sorry for the threadomancy, but another thread popped up which could help to explain this mystery. Unless I am mistaken, the movie takes place some time int he 1890s. Well, another thread, http://www.thefedoralounge.com/showthread.php?t=47775 , shows a catalog from 1890 and in it there is a hat called "the Fedora" which looks just like Holmes's hat and only came in black. So, it could be period, even if it was a fedora.
 

dr greg

One Too Many
nonsense

I thought it was a load of old cobblers personally, but very entertaining in its own right. I'm not a Holmes fanatic, but I have read them all and vastly prefer the Jeremy Brett incarnation, however, this is a Hollywood picture people, and they had him in contemporary situations fighting Nazis and stuff back in the 40's as I recall, so is what Guy Ritchie's done really worse than that?
 

Joeyeah_right

New in Town
Messages
27
Location
Hove, UK
Enjoyed the movie.

I really enjoyed the film - Great fun, and set up nicely for a possible sequel.

To be honest when I heard that Guy Ritchie was to be directing a 'Holmes' movie i thought "Oh no! It's going to be awful!", but after seeing the trailer for the film it intrigued me and made me want to watch it and I wasn't disappointed at all. Robert Downey Jr is excellent in the part, as too is Jude Law (who I didn't actually recognise as being him until I saw the credits at the end).

I suppose if you care about accuracy in terms of the books then you will be disappointed, but if you just want to enjoy a good, fun, well acted film then I would definitely recommend it! :)
 

chippy

New in Town
Messages
48
Location
Adelaide, South Australia
Apparently when given to Downey's he beat and bent it [homburg] till it looked like it did in the final film.

Art Fawcett said:
Here's where I am adamant. There is NO WAY this statement could be true. No amount of beating or bending is going to take the curl out of a Homburg. Here is where I object.
.

although completely at odds with the information given to Zendragon (below), it would appear you are correct (assuming my letter is correct) in not being persuaded Art.

Lock & Co have written me and stated that they supplied hats to the 'cast' and 'crew' and the hat worn by Mr R Downey Jr in the film is the LE Superfelt hat.

According to Lock & Co, its made with beaver felt, dark grey or black, brim is welted 2 1/4" and crown is approx 4 1/2" down to 4" at front



Zendragon said:
Some interesting new info... which I am not sure if they are on the mark with their response.

From Lock and Co:

"Dear Keith
Sorry, I told you the wrong hat.
It is actually our Dark Grey Homburg but the brim has been "played around with"!
The film actually premiered in London last night and one of my colleague tells me, that he wore the hat to the premiere.
Regards"
http://www.lockhatters.co.uk/Fedoras__Homburg___Pork_Pie-Homburg-P58.aspx

Now I am just not seeing it as that, but here is a shot from the premiere in London.

59148301.jpg
 

Yeps

Call Me a Cab
Messages
2,456
Location
Philly
Art Fawcett said:
If it does not have the brim roll, it is not a Homburg. There are variations of brim rolls but a flat brim has never been a Homburg option to my knowledge. Once it is flattened, it is no longer Homburg.


Here's where I am adamant. There is NO WAY this statement could be true. No amount of beating or bending is going to take the curl out of a Homburg. Here is where I object.

Jimmy, in the picture I see the sides still seem to hold their curl albeit in slighter form. Is this a true pic and my eyes are right? If so, this is what I would expect to achieve using a huge amount of steam and pressing for all I'm worth. Please note, the sides are still curled in this hat and NOT in the Downey hat.In fact, the Downey hat seems to have a downward curve, not upward. Is it possible? sure, with the right equipment, huge steam, and more talent than I have. Please note that the Downey hat brim seems to be relaxed into the shape it is where in the pic of JtL's lid it seems stressed, especially at the front and at the brim break on the sides. The stress comes from the binding and isn't displayed in Downey's hat. This is probably the biggest reason I don't believe this started life as a Homburg. That stress is virtually impossible to get rid of.

All of that being said please let me say that I have nothing invested in being right here and really don't care. I'm just trying to have bad information, if it is, not being read as "fact" just because I ( or any other hatter) didn't dispute it. I've often seen incorrect info become "common knowledge" for this reason alone.

I know I am bringing up an old debate, but I just watched the movie again and have taken the curl out a homburg recently.

I will not debate that the hat in the movie is not a homburg, that seems rather evident. But I think that that it could have been one at some point.

I found it rather easy to take the curl out a homburg with just a little steam and working by hand to soften it. I think that this looks a lot like the hat in the movie.
Photo32.jpg


Also, in my most recent watching, I noticed that the brim was very bumpy and uneven and looked like it was behaving a lot like my brim.
 

The Lark

One of the Regulars
Messages
125
Location
Melbourne, Australia
chippy said:
Lock & Co have written me and stated that they supplied hats to the 'cast' and 'crew' and the hat worn by Mr R Downey Jr in the film is the LE Superfelt hat.

According to the Lock & Co website this hat is listed as neither homburg nor fedora, but is in fact a trilby.
 

chippy

New in Town
Messages
48
Location
Adelaide, South Australia
The Lark said:
According to the Lock & Co website this hat is listed as neither homburg nor fedora, but is in fact a trilby.


yeah i noticed that as well, i figured it must just be a case of "I say tomartoe, you say tamaito" type thing

perhaps in Lock & Co eye's it is in fact, technically a trilby, but to R Downey Jr , internet folk and Americans in general they like the sound of calling it a Fedora better [huh]
 

cptjeff

Practically Family
Messages
564
Location
Greensboro, NC
Trilby is often used interchangeably with fedora. I think the main difference is that fedora is restricted to felt, where trilby covers other materials as well in it's definition.

But yeah, same thing. Trilby is a pretty distinctly British term though, so I'm not surprised Lock & Co uses it.
 

chippy

New in Town
Messages
48
Location
Adelaide, South Australia
cptjeff said:
Trilby is often used interchangeably with fedora. I think the main difference is that fedora is restricted to felt, where trilby covers other materials as well in it's definition.

But yeah, same thing. Trilby is a pretty distinctly British term though, so I'm not surprised Lock & Co uses it.

i tend to go along with you, ...but... it would seem Lock & Co do make a distinction between them..in my correspondence to them this came up as well as they do in fact sell a Fedora to, their Chelsea model hat, 2 1/2" brim 4 1/2 to 5" crown, larger shaped...
chelsea.jpg


As i understood it the distinction they make between it (a Fedora) and a Trilby is a Fedora has a broader crown (less taper) and wider brim and gives the overall appearance of a larger shaped hat
 

reetpleat

Call Me a Cab
Messages
2,681
Location
Seattle
I think I can shed some light on the issue here. When I saw the movie, I immediately spotted what I think is the "look" they were going for. There is acertain style from the 30s or 40s which is a black hat worn this way. there is afamous italian opera singer who has a famous photo in such a hat worn this way, ascot, etc. I have seen the look described as a bohemian artist kind of look. It involves a black soft hat, like a borsalino, worn in an intentionally casual way, with the front brim up and the back down, as if you do not care how it looks, but also giving it a certain pirate captain, cavalry officer flair. You see similar soft felt black hats on classic "godfather" stereotypes. Softer and flimsier than the classic american style. It gives a european, bohemian, even cavalier (literally) flair, and i am pretty convinced that this is the look that the costumer wass going for with this particular outfit for Holmes.. So, while I can not tell you if it would have been at all possible in this year, or if it was ever a homburg, which I doubt. but I can explain why the costumers would have chosen to use this hat for the character, even if it were not exactly period.
 

MontresorSioku

New in Town
Messages
1
Location
Pasadena, CA
chippy said:
although completely at odds with the information given to Zendragon (below), it would appear you are correct (assuming my letter is correct) in not being persuaded Art.

Lock & Co have written me and stated that they supplied hats to the 'cast' and 'crew' and the hat worn by Mr R Downey Jr in the film is the LE Superfelt hat.

According to Lock & Co, its made with beaver felt, dark grey or black, brim is welted 2 1/4" and crown is approx 4 1/2" down to 4" at front

I'm new to the site, and this thread is why i joined.

I think i have found a similar fedora! The fedora i just bought cost me about 140. Its very nice felt and from Stetson. Its black. The crown is 4" and the brim is only 2"...i was so shocked when i found out that im 1/4th of an inch less than the actual fedora..:/

17holmesfedoraj


Sorry for the "teen"ness of the picture. I cant really make the brim look like how battered and how part of the front part of the brim curls up and has a "bumpy" effect. My hat is new, so it either curls up to the "default" new out of the box way, or the "downturned" brim. ANd yes. those are Ozzy glasses.
 

Sam Craig

One Too Many
Messages
1,356
Location
Great Bend, Kansas
Let's not get too awfully carried away, gents.
It is a movie and it is filled with historic inaccuracies, just like any other movie.

By the way, you don't survive explosions, like the one at the dock in the first movie, either.
That's why they put this stuff in the movies ... cuz in real life it would KILL YOU!

It is a neat looking hat, but you can pick a lot of holes in Holmes' costuming from a historic standpoint, if that is what gets you happy.

Sam
 

Doug C

Practically Family
Messages
729
Dang it! I've read this whole freakin' thread and still don't know where to get a hat that looks really really close to RDJr's Sherlock Holmes hat. I don't care about whether it was period correct for the story or what it may have started life being called. When I first saw it, I thought.. "Borsalino" because it looked really soft and flexible, almost flimsy and reminded me of a Borsalino that I had that was like this. Hey MontresorSioku what's the name or model of that Stetson you got? ~ Doug
 

MCrider

A-List Customer
Messages
360
Location
hills of West Virginia
Dang it! I've read this whole freakin' thread and still don't know where to get a hat that looks really really close to RDJr's Sherlock Holmes hat. ~ Doug

I'd say go to Falcon Park Hattery. Hit his announcements page and there you have it. A good looking replica of the Holmes hat!
 

Forum statistics

Threads
107,029
Messages
3,026,704
Members
52,533
Latest member
RacerJ
Top