I need some HAT help!!!!

[Cepice]

I was just looking at the Gus crease @Rmccamey, that makes sense to me! Keeps a bit of the fedora vibe but the sides run longer like a cowboy style.

 

[Cepice]

So how far off is a fedora from a traditional cowboy hat? Hope this hasn't been rehashed a thousand times, but I can't find much. I feel like I'm swimming in a Stetsonian, I can't imagine if I'm wearing a 3"+ brim.

 

[Rmccamey]

So how far off is a fedora from a traditional cowboy hat? Hope this hasn't been rehashed a thousand times, but I can't find much. I feel like I'm swimming in a Stetsonian, I can't imagine if I'm wearing a 3"+ brim.

That is a loaded question with no real answer. Look through the Westerns threads and the What Hat are you Wearing threads to see general differences. Fedoras TEND to have shorter brims, pinch fronts and snapped brims, but that is a very general statement as there are fedoras that do not fit that description.

 

[Cepice]

Sorry, did not intend to stir up trouble. Just a bit new at the game. Since mine is an open crown, it seems to me I can cross over, but don't know the subtleties.

 

[belfastboy]

Sorry, did not intend to stir up trouble. Just a bit new at the game. Since mine is an open crown, it seems to me I can cross over, but don't know the subtleties.

An open crown hat is fun to play with. A spritz of water, some steam and you can bash it into whatever style you wish. As long as you don't put in hard sharp creasing you can steam it out and bash it in a different way. Play with it, play with differing styles until you achieve the style you like.

 

[jlee562]

So how far off is a fedora from a traditional cowboy hat? Hope this hasn't been rehashed a thousand times, but I can't find much. I feel like I'm swimming in a Stetsonian, I can't imagine if I'm wearing a 3"+ brim.

3" brim is nothin'!

This is my current favorite brim width, about 3"-3 1/4". Just IMHO, it's wide enough to clearly distinguish it from a wide brim fedora, but not so wide that you look like you just checked into a dude ranch.

 

[deadlyhandsome]

So how far off is a fedora from a traditional cowboy hat? Hope this hasn't been rehashed a thousand times, but I can't find much. I feel like I'm swimming in a Stetsonian, I can't imagine if I'm wearing a 3"+ brim.

The “traditional cowboy hat” takes in a lot of territory.

It’s common for men who are new to brimmed hats to prefer narrower brims and lower crowns. With time and exposure to other’s hats here in photos, many start to like wider brims and some also go for taller crowns. Some of my custom fedoras, and they are definitely fedoras, have 3 ⅛” brims. Of course, a lot depends on your hat/head size and your build. I have a hat arriving new week with a stingy 2 ⅞” brim; the narrowest I’ve commissioned in a long time.

I’d bet your Stetsonian (great hat by the way) doesn’t look like it has a wide brim to most of us.

 

[ILB Frank]

What Brent (deadlyhandsome) said.
That is exactly my "journey" with my hats. I started off wanting to keep a low profile (not being noticed too much) with my hat. But shortly after I started wearing a hat, I wanted more brim and more crown.
Granted, you'll find your personal limits - I think it will depend on your body size/height/etc. Just don't let some preconceived idea overrule what could be a great hat for you.
(Sorry for not providing specific advice.)

 

[nverette12]

Hi all!

Came across this old Stetson hat recently and have Done quite a bit of research about it but I'm wondering if someone on here could tell me a bit more about it! The hat is in excellent shape and the band is something I have never seen! Ideally I'd like to know the following:

- Year it was made
- Hat Style
- Rough idea if it's value (if allowed)
- Is the band original or custom, who knows?

Here's what I know as it is labeled on the hat:

- It says John B Stetson Company 3X Beaver
- It says "Shelden's Mens Wear Ottawa Kansas"
- It says XXX Stetson
- The tag says 7 3/8 Long Oval, and the back of it says United Hatters Cap & Millinery WKRS Int Union Registered
- inside the brim behind the sweatband has the number 13 written in white chalk
- the hat and band is in excellent condition aside from being a bit dirty. The band is genuine great condition leather, not sure of the metal type for the band.

Thanks!

 

[deadlyhandsome]

Hi all!

Came across this old Stetson hat recently and have Done quite a bit of research about it but I'm wondering if someone on here could tell me a bit more about it! The hat is in excellent shape and the band is something I have never seen! Ideally I'd like to know the following:

- Year it was made
- Hat Style
- Rough idea if it's value (if allowed)
- Is the band original or custom, who knows?

Here's what I know as it is labeled on the hat:

- It says John B Stetson Company 3X Beaver
- It says "Shelden's Mens Wear Ottawa Kansas"
- It says XXX Stetson
- The tag says 7 3/8 Long Oval, and the back of it says United Hatters Cap & Millinery WKRS Int Union Registered
- inside the brim behind the sweatband has the number 13 written in white chalk
- the hat and band is in excellent condition aside from being a bit dirty. The band is genuine great condition leather, not sure of the metal type for the band.

Thanks!

Looks 1970s. The hat band could well be aftermarket, but I’m not sure. It’s hard to say what model this was. It’s not from an era that brings better prices and the style and quality (3X) all point towards the lower price range of used fur felt hats.

 

[nverette12]

Looks 1970s. The hat band could well be aftermarket, but I’m not sure. It’s hard to say what model this was. It’s not from an era that brings better prices and the style and quality (3ax) all point towards the lower price range of used fur felt hats.

Fair enough! Good information. Thank you

 

[Rmccamey]

I have a solid black thin ribbon fedora that needs a refresh. I am going to change the ribbon to a wider, colored ribbon and I'm looking for recommendations. I don't want blue or silver. I lean toward burgundy or oxblood but a green might work...or a charcoal. Anyone have recommendations or examples to share? Thanks.

 

[belfastboy]

I have a solid black thin ribbon fedora that needs a refresh. I am going to change the ribbon to a wider, colored ribbon and I'm looking for recommendations. I don't want blue or silver. I lean toward burgundy or oxblood but a green might work...or a charcoal. Anyone have recommendations or examples to share? Thanks.

View attachment 485367

I just made a custom hat in a dark charcoal felt. Client wanted a light brown ribbon. I had doubts but we went with a Limestone ribbon and damn it looked good...sometimes the customer is always right!!!.

 

[Rmccamey]

That does seem to lean the black toward grey or charcoal. Very nice.

I just made a custom hat in a dark charcoal felt. Client wanted a light brown ribbon. I had doubts but we went with a Limestone ribbon and damn it looked good...sometimes the customer is always right!!!. View attachment 485386

 

[Just Daniel]

What a fun question and a great first answer. I thought dark green would be super interesting of you have a coat to go with it (maybe a houndstooth pattern?), but seeing that limestone ribbon might motivate me to put one on a black hat I have!

I have a solid black thin ribbon fedora that needs a refresh. I am going to change the ribbon to a wider, colored ribbon and I'm looking for recommendations. I don't want blue or silver. I lean toward burgundy or oxblood but a green might work...or a charcoal. Anyone have recommendations or examples to share? Thanks.

View attachment 485367

I just made a custom hat in a dark charcoal felt. Client wanted a light brown ribbon. I had doubts but we went with a Limestone ribbon and damn it looked good...sometimes the customer is always right!!!. View attachment 485386

 

[johnnycanuck]

So how far off is a fedora from a traditional cowboy hat? Hope this hasn't been rehashed a thousand times, but I can't find much. I feel like I'm swimming in a Stetsonian, I can't imagine if I'm wearing a 3"+ brim.

Loaded question. Most people view 2.5” brim to be a standard fedora brim and a 3” and up to be a western. Then you have an Open Road that is both City and country.
As for your Stetsonian feeling big. That’s a new hat wearing feeling. I felt my Akubra Federation to me massive until I got used to it. Now it feels small.
I remember reading one hat shop was selling lots of Open Road style hats but bashed in a Gus crease. Do you can have a western style in a fedora sized hat.
Post done pictures when you have time. Sounds interesting.
And welcome to the lounge
Johnny

 

[Attorneyatlaw]

Fashion Gurus, I need your help.

About 5 years ago, my significant other and I sold our homes and move to a condo. I had about 70 suits and gave most to a men’s shelter. Also, I had 39 fedoras (Dobbs, Stetsons, Biltmore etc) My law partners and I dress in the circa 1940s styles. Footjoys, Atkins, Edwin Clapp shoes, etc.

Never in these skinny suits like these young people are wearing now days lol. Well I put most of the remaining suits in storage. But sap two months ago, I started wearing my suits and hats again. Most of the hats are too big ha ha ha. i got older and lost some weight. I gave all of the size 7 5/8 to bailiffs at the court. They loved them. But I have 5 Biltmore President size 7 1/4. Perfect fit. I LOVE THEM. Brim 2 1/4. Look good as heck and the ladies all compliment me. Well I went online looking for more Biltmore Presidents and cannot find any. Hat Barn went out of business and Hats in the Belfry have none.

Does anyone on this list know a seller of Biltmore President Fedoras. Pleeeeeas!!!!

 

[CISO1969]

I followed directions found here for blocked felt,fur, wool hats like fedoras.

Used a 5 gallon white food grade bucket and lid, two smaller cans of Naptha, tongs, gloves and eye protection too.

Soaked all three hats 1. Stormy Cromer , 2. Woolrich mackinaw style plaid hunting hat, 3. Woolrich solid color Jones style wool hunting hat.

Wrung them out by hand and hung on a line to air dry after soaking 30 to 45 minutes. This was less about cleaning and more about killing any potential moth or carpet beetle eggs ... Well critter control proactive clean. I will mention all three had varying degrees of damage from minor to shotgun pattern .

Due to nature of heavy wool, lining and ear flap in wool it was many hours to dry not the two mentioned for blocked hats. In fact the Stormy Cromer hat is dry, mackinaw is close and the Jones is still drying. Started this at about 2pm today and all stated rates of drying are as of 8pm tonight, 6 hours on. Most drying was done on a line for about 4 hours.

If anyone can tell me how to date the Woolrich caps, I bought them mainly for my collection and for reference for patterns to base any hats I may make for myself.

Cost was about $10 plus per hat for all materials used in cleaning.

Hats had been previously treated by freezing and the Stormy Cromer was also vacuumed. After drying the SC was vacuumed again and placed in a ziplock for future wear and use and to protect it.

 

[Takimon]

Hi everyone! Super excited to share this find. We bought a home made in the 50s. In a hat box in the corner of our attic in a box we found this hat. I love it and want to learn more about it. Unfortunately, it's too small for my giant head. It looks like it's NOS. I see very little wear or damage. There is a bit of yellowing around the rim. Should I get this resized for my head or find a replica? Any insight you can provide would be greatly appreciated.

 

[buler]

Hi and welcome. You have found a very nice hat. Mallory's are very nice quality vintage hats. Yours dates to after the Stetson company bought out Mallory.

If you want to learn a lot more about Mallory, go to this thread -> https://www.thefedoralounge.com/threads/the-mallory-mile.41370/

What size is the hat? What size hat do you wear? Resizing a vintage hat is possible, but can distort the proportions of the hat and possibly damage the leather sweatband.