Pinnacle HH vs Battered SH

[onstar]

Which is softer and more comfortable; Pinnacle HH vs Battered SH ?

 

[jacketjunkie]

Which is softer and more comfortable; Pinnacle HH vs Battered SH ?

Haven't handled the Pinnacle HH but my sister owns a jacket made from Battered SH and I don't see any horsehide, especially none from Horween, be that soft and pliable.

 

[tpschar]

I have an Original Hercules in Pinnacle and a Shackleton in Battered Steer, and my Pinnacle is much softer - buttery soft, where the Battered Steer is more waxy.