Real McCoy's not expensive enough for you? Try this...

Discussion in 'Outerwear' started by MeachamLake, Feb 15, 2018.

  1. dudewuttheheck

    dudewuttheheck My Mail is Forwarded Here

    Messages:
    3,360
    I disagree strongly. While I am sure that there are many one off buyers for RMC, there are also one off buyers for Aero and Vanson as well.

    It's important to note that the people on this forum are generally into leather jackets above all else. People who buy Real McCoys jackets tend to be people that are into high quality/heritage or whatever you want to call it clothing such as @Benj , @Superfluous , and myself.

    It's still absolutely hilarious to me that Aero is fully accepted here while RMC is not. Neither company is perfect, but both jackets cost more than they need to and both are high quality and use expensive, high quality components.

    Why categorize RMC differently to Aero? That's absolutely ridiculous. The line of thinking in most cases when purchasing from either brand is very similar. However, there are qualities about RMC that make them more appealing to certain people such as myself. The stitching is neater and tighter in my experience and by a significant margin. I much prefer the leathers that RMC uses. Of course RMC is further along the point of diminishing returns than Aero is, but even Aero and ELC are very far along that point as well.

    You can get a tough, well made leather jacket crafted in a first world country for around $300. Aero is already way past this point.
     
    imabuddha and raulm1961 like this.
  2. Big J

    Big J Call Me a Cab

    Messages:
    2,966
    Location:
    Japan
    @Dudewhattheheck,

    Interesting comment.
    How many RMC products do you, Benj and Super collectively own?
    What makes you sure that your attitude to RMC purchases and ownership is the same as Japanese customers?
    How many Japanese have you surveyed regarding their attitudes towards owning RMC products?
    Have you got a copy of the questionnaire I could look at please (my Japanese is pretty good)?
    What was your sample size and how were people pre-selected?

    I suspect (and forgive me if I'm wrong), that you have in fact conducted no survey of Japanese people at all, and are in fact projecting your own opinions, mixed with some of the sales pap store staff were able to give you in limited English when you were on holiday in Japan.

    Sure, there must be some Japanese who are into the whole vintage look. I sometimes see even men wearing men's kimono that cost more than my wife's car out on a Sunday stroll.

    But I suspect that the vast majority of customers are buying these things for one season (because some Japanese magazine or TV show said it was cool and featured a celeb in one) and then getting bored of the look and going on to the next thing, selling their jacket on an auction site or taking it to a 'recycle' shop.

    Have a look at yahoo auctions japan. There are thousands of japanese flight jackets for sale at any one time, and they've all been worn for one season, so the seller wants the 'new' price.

    As for Aero, well, they aren't off the rack like RMC, they are made to order, so...
     
  3. Sloan1874

    Sloan1874 I'll Lock Up

    Messages:
    8,366
    Location:
    Glasgow
    I think Big J hit it with his last line. The difference between RMc and Aero is that the former is a done deal: when they release their line for that season/year, that's yer lot. Aero's produces one-offs, so it's a rolling roster of something 'different'. Don't get me wrong, I'm a big fan of RMc, but they're a different proposition, closer to Mister Freedom.
     
    ton312, Big J and Fanch like this.
  4. El Marro

    El Marro Call Me a Cab

    Messages:
    2,926
    Location:
    California
    That is a beautiful jacket man! I sometimes drool over the jackets Pendleton has released using native patterns and colors, although I have yet to buy one. I'd love to see some photos of this one when it arrives.
     
    AbbaDatDeHat likes this.
  5. ProteinNerd

    ProteinNerd My Mail is Forwarded Here

    Messages:
    3,782
    Location:
    Sydney
    When was RMC not accepted here? I just think being aimed at the Japanese market in terms of sizing they don’t fit a number of people here so aren’t on a lot of lists.
     
    Milesdeathescape, ton312 and Edward like this.
  6. I've seen 'one offs' several times in this thread. I'm not familiar with that phrase. Do you guys mean 'one ofs' ??
     
  7. El Marro

    El Marro Call Me a Cab

    Messages:
    2,926
    Location:
    California
    They mean one offs HD, although in this case the meaning is practically the same. This expression is British in origin.
     
  8. Oh, OK El Marro
    Thanks
     
    El Marro likes this.
  9. Big J

    Big J Call Me a Cab

    Messages:
    2,966
    Location:
    Japan
    I've never noticed an 'anti' RMC feeling on TFL.
    They don't make larger sizes, which means that a lot of western men can't wear them, so price and quality become a moot point.
    I'm not especially convinced that they are worth the price, they don't seem to be qualitatively superior to BR.
    IIRC the owner is that weird Japanese guy who bought the last flying Zero fighter from a US collection despite no one being qualified to train new pilots, the guy who wears an A-2 patched with kamikaze emblems, isn't he? That's kind of a nut-job thing to do here, like wearing a swastika around town. He also gets wheeled out on TV to 'comment' on the golden era whenever Japanese TV shows Indy Jones movies, wearing an A-2 and a fedora.
    At best, a harmless fancy dress lover.
    At worst, a shady warcrime denier.
    I can't be bothered to look into it anymore than that, and I don't have to- I have to choose other brands based on size anyway.
     
  10. dudewuttheheck

    dudewuttheheck My Mail is Forwarded Here

    Messages:
    3,360
    You are in fact incorrect. I have never spoken to anyone from RMC in any location other than to point to which shirts my brother wanted to try on.

    I said myself that I am sure there are many 'one off' type customers of RMC. This means that I am conceding that many of the Japanese buyers are exactly as stated previously.

    I am talking about the people that I know that have purchased RMC. Go look at denimbro and you'll see what I mean.

    These are not merely my own opinions and there is no 'sales pap'. This has been my experience based on the jackets I have handled and the people who own RMC that I have personally talked to.

    And yes, there is definitely a general anti-RMC and pro-Aero feel on this forum compared to other forums that discuss leather jackets.
     
    raulm1961 likes this.
  11. Benj

    Benj One of the Regulars

    Messages:
    240
    Location:
    Los Angeles
    Forgive me...

    What makes you sure that your attitude to RMC purchases and ownership is the same as Japanese customers?
    How many Japanese have you surveyed regarding their attitudes towards owning RMC products?
    Have you got a copy of the questionnaire I could look at please (although my Japanese is not quite so good)?
    What was your sample size and how were people pre-selected?

    I suspect (and forgive me if I'm wrong), that you have in fact conducted no survey of Japanese people at all, and are in fact projecting your own opinions.


    I think that when @dudewuttheheck refers to "anti-rmc" feelings he's referring to the inevitable comments on price and how it isn't justifiable. You almost never see these comments on Aero products, which are also extremely expensive, and you almost always see these comments somewhere in a thread that mentions RMC.

    I also believe that you do not have the right guy in your head. I think you are thinking of Okamoto, the owner of Toys McCoy. Here is the owner of the Real McCoy's, Hitoshi Tsujimoto, and I, at this year's Inspiration in Los Angeles.

    [​IMG]
     
  12. Big J

    Big J Call Me a Cab

    Messages:
    2,966
    Location:
    Japan
    @dudewhattheheck, you said;
    "People who buy RMC tend to be people who are into high quality and heritage..such as...myself" whilst the rest of us are merely into "leather jackets".
    Ok, so how many do you own? One?
    Or do you have many? I'm genuinely asking.

    The fact that RMC only makes jackets for small guys kind of indicates that their target demographic isn't the majority of non-Japanese men.

    They don't want my custom, why should I cut them some slack for offering off-the-peg jackets at twice the price of an Aero?

    I know you've read my comments about authentic jacket lengths and quality (and all the trouble that's got me) so I'm very interested in what makes you a connoisseur of high-quality and heritage clothing (urghh, hate that expression), whilst I'm presumably not? It's quite a claim to make for yourself.

    Remember, I've seen the photo of you with the drainpipe shiny suit pants ;)

    I suspect that you're attracted to these brands for the exclusivity and high price point; it makes you feel good. That's fine if so, it's natural to do things that make you feel good.

    And no, I shall not go to denimbro for information about leather jackets. Sounds like a 'niche' pick-up site.

    @Benj,
    Hello. How many RMC jackets do you own?

    But it does seem that I was wrong about RMC's owner. It's that other guy. I can admit when I'm wrong.

    Speaking of size, I don't imagine that Japanese guy in the photo is a giant who started a company making jackets too small for him to wear, so I'm guessing you're about a size 36 or so. So you can wear the jackets. That's fine. Good for you! Enjoy! I can't. I'm a size 48. Issue A-2s also came in size 48. RMC jackets don't. Big black mark against them right there in my book.

    Surveys? I'm afraid I have none. I've only lived here for 20 years and had but a couple of hundred random conversations with Japanese jacket owners in coffee shops and stuff. But that is a lot of anecdotal evidence.

    I'm honestly not trying to pick fights with anyone. RMC jackets are way more expensive than the competition, and not made to order. And they only make small sizes, so naturally they won't get a lot of love amongst westerners, I think (but hey, maybe I'm wrong about that too. Could be).

    As I've said about other brands, 'over-built' jackets are IMHO less accurate reproductions. There was a war on. Jackets were made as quickly as possible, to the lowest possible standards, with whatever acceptable materials, by people with the lowest possible training hours. That's the ultimate goal of the best reproduction, surely?

    'Good enough for government work'.

    Better than that is fantasy, is it not?

    (Again, please don't read this with any malice or ill-intent, I'm merely discussing ideas).
     
    kliffjumper123 likes this.
  13. Sloan1874

    Sloan1874 I'll Lock Up

    Messages:
    8,366
    Location:
    Glasgow
    RMC products are more expensive than Aero, by more than 100 per cent in many cases. Because of this, I tend to hunt eBay looking for used bargains than buy first hand. I think it's only natural that a forum would tend to favour brands that are within the reach of a greater number of people, but again I think there's an apple and oranges comparison being made here - Aero are doing bespoke, RMC are off-the-peg. People are generally going to have more to chat about when it comes to something that was made to their specifications, whether it's a leather jacket, a suit or whatever, so I don't think there's anything partiularly 'anti-RMC' going on, their stuff, which I must reiterate that I love, is just less 'comment-worthy'.
     
    Milesdeathescape, Edward and Alz like this.
  14. ProteinNerd

    ProteinNerd My Mail is Forwarded Here

    Messages:
    3,782
    Location:
    Sydney
    Lets be fair though, an off the rack RMC jacket is about US$800 more than a custom Aero....thats a pretty significant difference in price, its kinda creeping up to almost double the price...to merely say they are both "expensive" and imply they are similarly priced isn't really an accurate representation of the situation.
     
  15. Big J

    Big J Call Me a Cab

    Messages:
    2,966
    Location:
    Japan
    I think I recall Superfluous commenting once about his compulsive behavior to search out something 'more' all the time (hence his handle), cars, clothes, that sort of thing.
    I wouldn't knock that.
    I do think that some people want more exclusivity, something more 'special', and longer wait times, higher prices, over-building and exotic materials appeal to that instinct.

    I'm only concerned with accuracy. I think it's the difference between a reproduction and a costume. If other people aren't, that's perfectly fine, but we will not be in agreement about how 'good' something is.

    With modern technology we could make a banging new Stonehenge, with perfectly smooth flat stones and square corners and all, but I don't think anyone would say it has an authentic feel.
     
    Milesdeathescape likes this.
  16. red devil

    red devil My Mail is Forwarded Here

    Messages:
    3,290
    Location:
    London
    Interesting thread, I have been twice to the RMC store in Harajuku / Shibuya with a very serious intent to buy:
    - The first time, I ended up with a Tenjin works JW02. It was the only place that had a jacket that fit me well at the time. I tried on a sample which fit like a glove, just needing longer sleeves which is not a problem, since all their products are made to order. @Big J they will make your size if you ever want it. They use veg-tanned cowhide and not shinki which can be a let down to some.
    - The second time, I had lost some weight, and thought that I would be successful and ended up.... with the little wing from freewheelers. Again the fit of that jacket was better than anything I tried at RMC. Freewheelers' fit varies widely by jacket, so there is a chance of finding a correct fit as long as you're not beyond a certain size
    The problem with RMC in both occasions was the fit, I spent a lot of time at the shop trying sizes 42 and 44, even 40... but nothing fit well. Same problem with Flathead, the fit just does not work.
    So if you're lucky enough to be able to wear an RMC jacket well, than it is definitely a very good brand, Flathead is very similar in this aspect.
     
    El Marro and Big J like this.
  17. Monitor

    Monitor

    Messages:
    14,372
    lol I think that's just me.

    But I still don't get it - They make nice jackets, well constructed and all but compared to some other brands, the leather they use is thin, sometimes flimsy thin and they're all OTR, which is why I don't get the price. I'd rank them at Schott price range but not two freaking grands.

    I'm not anti-RMC, I'm anti-senseless pricing. It had become a standard for the Japanese brand to be asking several thousand dollars for the same old designs they constantly copy off each other all the time. They're all OTR, all the same old Shinki and all just old.

    But then again, I often see this sorta thing, where people are convinced that everything coming out of Japan is somehow magically superior. Same with people who are convinced that anything that costs more is also better.
     
  18. Doctor Damage

    Doctor Damage My Mail is Forwarded Here

    Messages:
    3,662
    Location:
    Ontario
    There's a bunch of people who think that anything made in the USA is better, too. Or handmade is always better. One problem is that even the experts around here often don't seem to know what they're talking about; most people come to conclusions then look for evidence to support their conclusion, which is ass-backwards. More broadly, there is a snob factor involved, what I mean is that buying expensive stuff from the supposedly best companies allows you to look down at the less-informed or less-clever people who shop at the mall or whatever. That shows up in this forum, too. The people who buy a $2000 jacket then laugh at someone wearing a $100 mall jacket, but then almost never wear their $2000 jacket so it never wears in or weathers and ends up looking like a stiff plastic thing like a mall jacket. Another thing is that some people make too much money. Whenever I look at pricing for things I always think, "item A is twice as expensive as item B, but is it twice as good?" If not, then I'm not paying twice as good. It's commonly understood (or maybe not) that as price goes up there is a diminishing return since quality can't go up at the same rate.
     
  19. Mich486

    Mich486 One Too Many

    Messages:
    1,540
    Many of these heritage brands thrive on people’s idea that to be well dressed in a casual environment you need to wear very expensive workwear. For example, jeans can’t be Levi’s... they have to be 20oz thick from that unknown Japanese mill. What is funny is that then people buy these brands with the idea that these days that’s the only way they have to achieve the look you could achieve in the past with cheapo stuff (like Levi’s). In my personal experience I find that is not true at all (especially with denim).





    Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
     
  20. Big J

    Big J Call Me a Cab

    Messages:
    2,966
    Location:
    Japan
    Are dudewhattheheck and Benj the same person?
    Same build.
    Same hair.
    Same jacket.
    Doppelgängers found at last!
    Awesome! You guys could save a fortune by sharing your wardrobes!
     
    Monitor likes this.

Share This Page

  1. This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
    By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.