Want to buy or sell something? Check the classifieds
  • The Fedora Lounge is supported in part by commission earning affiliate links sitewide. Please support us by using them. You may learn more here.

Side By Side/ Hat Comparisons

splintercellsz

I'll Lock Up
Messages
6,137
Location
Somewhere in Time
1900s/1915s Stetson Exposition Medals

I'll let the photos do the talking.
The sweat on one 1900s expo was replaced, and a 1915s expo is missing it's sweat. other than that, each has is almost pristine and damage free.

Notice the differences in felt finishing
88c4a706ae9e94b99a80271c82d173fa.jpg
35ea2c42b89f8ad5fa0b79ac248811c0.jpg
3b71edacaa38ee7b94f201b8b5a2d402.jpg
8aec30a61c74f512bbd1e02907d3859e.jpg
b9dac4d0894707666881ee24808767ba.jpg
faba861542c0480d2d26b36c8510e1cf.jpg
ad21802228df670d65dc8fcfe86c6e4a.jpg
1561d77d9cff8d0a329da3c1fe78520b.jpg
da6c4350a7d974fae79b14887ed664a5.jpg
6196ad3b4259b66cfb0003078165a881.jpg
 

Daniele Tanto

I'll Lock Up
Messages
4,119
Location
Verona - Italia
1900s/1915s Stetson Exposition Medals

I'll let the photos do the talking.
The sweat on one 1900s expo was replaced, and a 1915s expo is missing it's sweat. other than that, each has is almost pristine and damage free.

Notice the differences in felt finishing
88c4a706ae9e94b99a80271c82d173fa.jpg
Bravo! Lavoro splendido.
Complimenti Justin
I am boring beyond measure, pity for me they are all small, and good for you are of your size, but it is a bore to repeat it
 

moontheloon

I'll Lock Up
Messages
8,590
Location
NJ
I was just taking a look at my two Stetson Medalist Eagles together and couldn’t help but notice a few things

Even though they are both Vita Felt ... which puts them generally in that ‘41 to ‘46 range they are quite different hats.

after studying them pretty closely I’m gathering that the brown one is the earlier piece... I’m guessing in the ‘41-‘42 range
... then the blue sometime after ... but not much.

If anyone has an opposing theory I’m all ears ... absolutely

So a few differences

Brims
brown - 2 1/2
blue- 2 3/4

Ribbon
brown - 1 3/4
blue - 1 1/2

Sweat
brown - 2
blue - 1 5/8

Block
brown - 348
blue - 165

other than that is the obvious ...
brown - lined
blue - unlined

brown - reeded sweat
blue - unreeded

also the sweat materials are quite different

the bow keepers are also different ... as you can see the keep on the brown hat has a layer pleat.

the brown has the feather applied at the factory that this model came with ... the feather in the blue is missing but there is a remnant of it.
... it’s hard to see in the photo but there is a piece of a red feather behind the bow

brown has the older style 3 block manufacturer tag
blue has the later style more prominent in 40s hats



I’ll let the photos tell the rest



06ce8c6cf3aadbf988ce93f4fb863ed8.jpg

f7de3b3680c9d179d055b87a24baafe6.jpg

6f0642eb6c27e36ca921278f25666e1f.jpg

8af5ab22a133024f1ec88469bbbbb39f.jpg

a6552fc4773fcd7b3af674df3344b430.jpg

2182c225425a86e069021181b5537666.jpg

57c52aadeec12551a73e51eacda653a4.jpg

a1f92f8a4cce7ff990734cb2d8eb3b85.jpg

8bde15160c6774644b957297499117f7.jpg

d39418792b1545b7c7960a80c7d9db04.jpg

cbe3ea0f8fd57ea94b8157e392f6ff23.jpg


and here if you look closely you can see the remnant of a red feather... very tough to photograph but it is there
70d0c2224baec9f716f0946667b4631a.jpg



Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
Last edited:

RJR

Messages
10,620
Location
Iowa
I was just taking a look at my two Stetson Medalist Eagles together an couldn’t help but notice a few things

Even though they are both Vita Felt ... which puts them generally in that ‘41 to ‘46 range they are quite different hats.

after studying them pretty closely I’m gathering that the brown one is the earlier piece... I’m guessing in the ‘41-‘42 range
... then the blue sometime after ... but not much.

If anyone has an opposing theory I’m all ears ... absolutely

So a few differences

Brims
brown - 2 1/2
blue- 2 3/4

Ribbon
brown - 1 3/4
blue - 1 1/2

Sweat
brown - 2
blue - 1 5/8

Block
brown - 348
blue - 165

other than that is the obvious ...
brown - lined
blue - unlined

brown - reeded sweat
blue - unreeded

also the sweat materials are quite different

the bow keepers are also different ... as you can see the keep on the brown hat has a layer pleat.

the brown has the feather applied at the factory that this model came with ... the feather in the blue is missing but there is a remnant of it.
... it’s hard to see in the photo but there is a piece of a red feather behind the bow

brown has the older style 3 block manufacturer tag
blue has the later style more prominent in 40s hats



I’ll let the photos tell the rest



06ce8c6cf3aadbf988ce93f4fb863ed8.jpg

f7de3b3680c9d179d055b87a24baafe6.jpg

6f0642eb6c27e36ca921278f25666e1f.jpg

8af5ab22a133024f1ec88469bbbbb39f.jpg

a6552fc4773fcd7b3af674df3344b430.jpg

2182c225425a86e069021181b5537666.jpg

57c52aadeec12551a73e51eacda653a4.jpg

a1f92f8a4cce7ff990734cb2d8eb3b85.jpg

8bde15160c6774644b957297499117f7.jpg

d39418792b1545b7c7960a80c7d9db04.jpg

cbe3ea0f8fd57ea94b8157e392f6ff23.jpg


and here if you look closely you can see the remnant of a red feather... very tough to photograph but it is there
70d0c2224baec9f716f0946667b4631a.jpg



Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Beautiful hats,the comparison is interesting.
 
Messages
17,903
Location
Nederland
I was just taking a look at my two Stetson Medalist Eagles together an couldn’t help but notice a few things

Even though they are both Vita Felt ... which puts them generally in that ‘41 to ‘46 range they are quite different hats.

after studying them pretty closely I’m gathering that the brown one is the earlier piece... I’m guessing in the ‘41-‘42 range
... then the blue sometime after ... but not much.

If anyone has an opposing theory I’m all ears ... absolutely

So a few differences

Brims
brown - 2 1/2
blue- 2 3/4

Ribbon
brown - 1 3/4
blue - 1 1/2

Sweat
brown - 2
blue - 1 5/8

Block
brown - 348
blue - 165

other than that is the obvious ...
brown - lined
blue - unlined

brown - reeded sweat
blue - unreeded

also the sweat materials are quite different

the bow keepers are also different ... as you can see the keep on the brown hat has a layer pleat.

the brown has the feather applied at the factory that this model came with ... the feather in the blue is missing but there is a remnant of it.
... it’s hard to see in the photo but there is a piece of a red feather behind the bow

brown has the older style 3 block manufacturer tag
blue has the later style more prominent in 40s hats



I’ll let the photos tell the rest



06ce8c6cf3aadbf988ce93f4fb863ed8.jpg

f7de3b3680c9d179d055b87a24baafe6.jpg

6f0642eb6c27e36ca921278f25666e1f.jpg

8af5ab22a133024f1ec88469bbbbb39f.jpg

a6552fc4773fcd7b3af674df3344b430.jpg

2182c225425a86e069021181b5537666.jpg

57c52aadeec12551a73e51eacda653a4.jpg

a1f92f8a4cce7ff990734cb2d8eb3b85.jpg

8bde15160c6774644b957297499117f7.jpg

d39418792b1545b7c7960a80c7d9db04.jpg

cbe3ea0f8fd57ea94b8157e392f6ff23.jpg


and here if you look closely you can see the remnant of a red feather... very tough to photograph but it is there
70d0c2224baec9f716f0946667b4631a.jpg



Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Great comparison, Anthony. All I need is a few of these for myself so I can do my own comparison!
 

Forum statistics

Threads
107,278
Messages
3,032,897
Members
52,748
Latest member
R_P_Meldner
Top