- Messages
- 18,301
- Location
- New York City
The Little Kidnappers (1953) with John Whitely, Vincent Winter, Duncan Macrae, Jean Anderson, and Adrienne Corri
Two just-orphaned boys, aged four and eight, who go to live with their grandparents in Nova Scotia in the early 1900s, find it a bumpy adjustment in general. One specific bump is that their grandfather, a strict religious disciplinarian, denies them their only real wish: a dog.
Gruff grandpa is also in the middle of a land dispute, which reveals both his distrust of the law and his hatred of the Boers, since his son – the boys’ father – died fighting them in the Boer War. There's also an aunt there fearing spinsterhood as her crush on a local doctor is unrequited.
Two things surprise you: first, that anyone made a movie from this story at all, and second, how incredibly good it is. It's proof again that the number one thing in storytelling is to get the audience to care about the characters.
In The Little Kidnappers, you care about the characters because they are real, flawed people. The two boys who lost their parents and have been shipped from their place of birth, Scotland, to a strange country seem almost shell shocked as they have a preternatural calmness to them.
The boys, played by John Whitely and Vincent Winter, take reasonably well to their spartan existence on a provincial farm in a remote Canadian province. They even take reasonably well to their dogmatic grandfather, played by Duncan Macrae, but still, they want a dog.
Stuck in the middle of the two boys, their grandfather, and the pining aunt is "grandma," played by Jean Anderson. She is a beaten-down yet kind woman who has found a way to make life with a dictatorial man work, though it clearly takes a toll on her.
Everything you need to know about “grandma” comes in one scene when the grandfather takes one of the boys out to the woodshed for punishment. It breaks her heart, but she tries to convince herself it’s fair. For her, there is no other possible attitude.
A lot surprisingly happens in this "small" story – the titular kidnapping, a few legal disputes, a love story revived, a traumatic first week of school, and even the trial of an eight-year-old boy – are just the highlights.
It all works because nobody is perfect and most evolve. Grandfather, we learn, had a harsh upbringing, but in his own way, he is sincerely trying to do what he thinks is right and even changes a bit as life forces him to look at his convictions and decisions. It's believable growth.
The boys, of course, do some growing up, and both grandma and the aunt are changed by the pileup of events. It's honest life coming at you on the screen, all advanced by strong and sincere performances. You become fully – absolutely fully – vested in these characters.
How they found not just one but two child actors of Whiteley's and Winter's abilities is hard to fathom, but these are professional actors who are also children. Macrae, Anderson, and the aunt, played by Adrienne Corri, all give moving performances as well.
Filmed on a small budget, in black and white, with the Highlands of Scotland standing in for Nova Scotia, you feel transported back to the early twentieth century. It helps that to create a poor farm from that era, you basically just have to strip away everything modern.
No spoilers, but know that the movie ends with an incredible one-two punch of a trial where men of character act with honor so remote to us today, it feels like life on another planet – followed by an epilogue that will have you in tears if you have any compassion in you.
Taking the movie at face value, it was a harsher time and a more honorable time, as many believed in or believed they had to act like they believed in the Bible. Today, we are, thankfully, less harsh, but also less honorable. One day, we will hopefully get the balance right.
The Little Kidnappers is everything a "small" movie should be: a good story that transports you to a different time and place, while creating characters you care deeply about who evolve as they face challenges and tests of courage – all with no special effects used or needed.



