Red Wing Pecos 1155 vs Tecovas – Style & Comfort Only

[Rick Dalton]

Hi everyone,


I’m trying to decide between the Red Wing Pecos 1155 and a pair of Tecovas, and I’d love to hear your thoughts — purely in terms of style and comfort.


Construction, durability, and build quality aside (we all know Red Wing has the edge there).

If anyone has experience with both brands, I’d really appreciate a comparison.

Thanks in advance!

 

[Rick Dalton]

Anybody?

 

[Tom71]

Sorry, no expo with Tecova. I do own a pair of Pecos though, and they are my most comfortable Roper style boot. You won´t go wrong with them, but you have to be careful with sizing. They do fit pretty slim, so most retailers recommend to size up from your usual RW size. The local RW satores sell in an "E" width, so I got my normal size, and it fits perfectly.

 

[Rick Dalton]

Sorry, no expo with Tecova. I do own a pair of Pecos though, and they are my most comfortable Roper style boot. You won´t go wrong with them, but you have to be careful with sizing. They do fit pretty slim, so most retailers recommend to size up from your usual RW size. The local RW satores sell in an "E" width, so I got my normal size, and it fits perfectly.

Thank you so much for your response!
I’m really trying to decide, and this is my first step into cowboy/roper/heritage boots. I’m a bit nervous because of all the stories about how some boots feel like walking on wood with no cushioning, but I understand that’s usual for the Red Wing Heritage line.

From what I’ve read, the Pecos 1155 are supposed to have a bit more cushioning in the sole, which is encouraging. My feet are approximately 10.5 cm wide and 27.5 cm long, and I have the opportunity to buy a pair that is practically new — E width, US 10.5 (EU 43.5).

I’d really appreciate any advice on whether this size and width would likely be a good fit for me.

Thank you again for your help!

 

[Rick Dalton]

according to red wing website app I should get 11D so I guess I'm out of luck

 

[Bfd70]

I have not owned RW pecos but have owned 6 or 7 other models. I have owned Tecovas western boots. RW are a much heavier sturdy boot. The require break in. Tecovas by comparison are lighter and more comfortable initially. Adding more to the soup I think Ariat at the same price are more comfortable than tecovas. However, at RW price point I think these lucchese are by far the best bet. Well made, super comfortable and stylish (ish). They are my daily drivers right now.

https://www.lucchese.com/products/rusty-dark-brown

 

[NAB]

I have a pair of the older black Pecos and have owned a pair of the 1155s too. Very, very solid boots and noticeably sturdier than Iron Rangers I've handled. Comfort-wise, they're pretty good but I did end up adding superfeet insoles for long days on my feet. On the style front, it's a preference but the RWs can more obviously handle a days work and are a bit less overtly Western.

As for the sizing, I think the 10.5 might be ok based on my experience but worry the E would be a bit wide.

 

[Rick Dalton]

I have a pair of the older black Pecos and have owned a pair of the 1155s too. Very, very solid boots and noticeably sturdier than Iron Rangers I've handled. Comfort-wise, they're pretty good but I did end up adding superfeet insoles for long days on my feet. On the style front, it's a preference but the RWs can more obviously handle a days work and are a bit less overtly Western.

As for the sizing, I think the 10.5 might be ok based on my experience but worry the E would be a bit wide.

I would love to add an insole for comfort. Perhaps E width could offer more space for it?

 

[Rick Dalton]

I have not owned RW pecos but have owned 6 or 7 other models. I have owned Tecovas western boots. RW are a much heavier sturdy boot. The require break in. Tecovas by comparison are lighter and more comfortable initially. Adding more to the soup I think Ariat at the same price are more comfortable than tecovas. However, at RW price point I think these lucchese are by far the best bet. Well made, super comfortable and stylish (ish). They are my daily drivers right now.

https://www.lucchese.com/products/rusty-dark-brown

lucchese are beautiful but I have option to buy pecos used for a third of a price of a new

 

[NAB]

I would love to add an insole for comfort. Perhaps E width could offer more space for it?

Crossed my mind as well. Your mileage may vary of course — boots are never an exact science.

 

[Rick Dalton]

I regularly wear Caterpillar boots (kind of Timberland-style work boots), and I can walk in them all day without any problems — even long walks of 10 km or more are fine for me.


How different do you think the Pecos would feel in comparison? They don’t have a leather sole, and from what I’ve seen (including Rose Anvil videos), Caterpillar boots have fewer sole components than the Pecos. I would also assume that Caterpillar boots are not necessarily more shock-absorbing than the components used in the Pecos.

CAT:

Pecos:

Because of that, I’m thinking the Pecos might not be as uncomfortable at the beginning as some Red Wing Heritage models. What's your opinion?

 

[El Marro]

I have owned boots by both brands and for comfort and durability I think Red Wing gets the nod. Tecova makes a fine boot, I will say that I have experienced more variety in sizing and fit between pairs that were supposed to be the same size, but I like their boots and the fact that you can get some interesting hides and finishes without paying top dollar for them.

 

[Rick Dalton]

I have owned boots by both brands and for comfort and durability I think Red Wing gets the nod. Tecova makes a fine boot, I will say that I have experienced more variety in sizing and fit between pairs that were supposed to be the same size, but I like their boots and the fact that you can get some interesting hides and finishes without paying top dollar for them.

Would you agree that the Red Wing Work line (like the Pecos) is much more comfortable than the Heritage line? Is it comparable to something like Caterpillar work boots in terms of comfort?

 

[El Marro]

Would you agree that the Red Wing Work line (like the Pecos) is much more comfortable than the Heritage line? Is it comparable to something like Caterpillar work boots in terms of comfort?

Yes I would. I can’t speak specifically about Caterpillar boots since I haven’t owned them, but Red Wing work boots in general are very comfortable, especially if you get a good insole to wear with them. I have never owned iron ranges, but I did have a pair of the heritage engineer boot from Redwing and I did not find it to be very comfortable to walk around in.

 

[ProfG]

I bought the pecos boots and have been wearing them for a month or two. Pros: look great and seem well-made. Cons: not the most comfortable boots I own, very pronounced heel slip at first. I went down half a size from my Brannock measurement and honestly I might recommend going down a full size.

Pro tip: I got a killer deal from Hamilton and Adams, check them out if you do buy them.

 

[Rick Dalton]

I bought the pecos boots and have been wearing them for a month or two. Pros: look great and seem well-made. Cons: not the most comfortable boots I own, very pronounced heel slip at first. I went down half a size from my Brannock measurement and honestly I might recommend going down a full size.

Pro tip: I got a killer deal from Hamilton and Adams, check them out if you do buy them.

Thanks! Did the heel slip become less noticeable after some time? Would you say the boots have some cushioning, or are they quite hard with little shock absorption, compared to, let’s say, Timberlands or similar boots?
Did you try adding an insole for more cushioning?

 

[Rick Dalton]

I have a pair of the older black Pecos and have owned a pair of the 1155s too. Very, very solid boots and noticeably sturdier than Iron Rangers I've handled. Comfort-wise, they're pretty good but I did end up adding superfeet insoles for long days on my feet. On the style front, it's a preference but the RWs can more obviously handle a days work and are a bit less overtly Western.

As for the sizing, I think the 10.5 might be ok based on my experience but worry the E would be a bit wide.

Your experience gives me a lot of hope for these boots. I’m hoping for something similar — a comfortable enough boot with some cushioning on its own, and the option to add an insole for extra cushioning. Would you say that a wider shaft (compared to a typical western boot) ruins the look, or is it not really noticeable? I was hoping that if I go with the 1155 instead of Tecovas, I’d get a boot that’s designed for quick on and off (thanks to the wider shaft) and that — due to its construction — will hold up better over years of everyday use. That’s my hope, at least.

 

[Rick Dalton]

I’ve missed out on the Pecos (and I really, really kick myself over that).


Some of you suggested Ariat as a more comfortable option among budget brands.


If you had to choose, would you go with the Ariat Heritage Roper, or something from Tecovas, like The Jake (the model with the rubber outsole over leather)?


Comfort is a big factor for me, but I’d also like something that feels solid long-term. Curious to hear your experiences.