Help with dating these two vintage fedora's anyone?

1on1 · Apr 28, 2020

Hi hatters! I picked up these two fedora's the other day..hopefully fellow hat lovers can chime in with insights (i.e. period /value)
Much obliged

231460[/ATTACH]

The stetson has moth tracks as seen..and a bit crumpled.
The mexican panama below appears to be indecent shape although i'm not sure if its missing a ribbon or not.

jlee562 · Apr 29, 2020

The interior tags under the sweat on the Stetson would help, but 40's-50's is a pretty safe ballpark. There are a handful of those Nutria Quality lids around the lounge.

1on1 · Apr 29, 2020

Didnt find any under the sweats, any idea on the second lid ( i like that term "lid" hehe)

deadlyhandsome · Apr 29, 2020

1on1 said:
Didnt find any under the sweats, any idea on the second lid ( i like that term "lid" hehe)

I’ve never seen that exact palm hat, but there are many that are very similar.

Love that nutria! Great color combination and proportions. If it was my size I’d try to talk you out of it, moth damage and all.

1on1 · Apr 29, 2020

DH- Assuming i were to sling it somewhere online, how much would you expect it to fetch?
I've been reading that a nutria stetson is a bit uncommon apparently.

1on1 · Apr 29, 2020

any hint on the mexican ?

deadlyhandsome · Apr 29, 2020

1on1 said:
DH- Assuming i were to sling it somewhere online, how much would you expect it to fetch?
I've been reading that a nutria stetson is a bit uncommon apparently.

I’m not much of a hat appraiser. I’d also need to see the damaged area(s) better. My other big problem is that I really only know what I’d pay for a hat in my size, and in vintage hats size matters. 7 1/4 is a good and popular size, but I’m a 7 5/8+ and that same hat in my size is often twice as much as a 7 1/4.

I see palm hats very similar to yours, with a ribbon treatment of some sort, in the $30 range.

deadlyhandsome · Apr 29, 2020

1on1 said:
DH- Assuming i were to sling it somewhere online, how much would you expect it to fetch?
I've been reading that a nutria stetson is a bit uncommon apparently.

If you want to put it up for sale we have a classifieds section here. It’s your target audience and some serious collectors regularly come by. It’s also a place where the buyers know the market and it’s rare that hats that are overpriced sell. You can list it on the high side and if no one bites you can always lower it. The best part is you get to keep all your money as there aren’t any seller’s or buyer’s fees.

1on1 · Apr 29, 2020

sounds like a plan - till soon.

& thanks!

jlee562 · Apr 29, 2020

Hard to say what really is "rare" or not. Anecdotally, I feel like I see more nutria hats than say, 7xCB or 100s.

1on1 · Apr 29, 2020

i was basing it on an old post i read somewhere (on this forum) that "vintage habedashers" mentioned that in all his years of hunting vintage, he had never come across a "nutria" - its all relative i suppose but i consider him a serious authority on all things vintage.

carouselvic · Apr 29, 2020

1on1 said:
i was basing it on an old post i read somewhere (on this forum) that "vintage habedashers" mentioned that in all his years of hunting vintage, he had never come across a "nutria" - its all relative i suppose but i consider him a serious authority on all things vintage.

Spencer has owned and sold countless nutria hats.

jlee562 · Apr 29, 2020

Well, I'm pretty sure Brent has one; I have one; and I sold on here too. There's definitely a few more here

See also: https://www.thefedoralounge.com/threads/the-official-stetson-nutria-quality-thread.55014/

1on1 · Apr 29, 2020

carouselvic- He may well have, but i didnt check to see how old this particular remark in question was..i am just now starting to look into these hats so my research is in its infancy.
jlee562- i'm not suggesting i am the sole owner of this model hat, i'm sure it wont be too difficult to find another person who owns one, just basing my remarks on the remarks of one individual who "has bought and sold a lot of hats" as carouselvic stated.
If i find the thread again i'll fill you both in..

1on1 · Apr 29, 2020

YES infact i did find it..his remarks are from Sept 3 2008, remark # 4 , thread titled " Stetson Nutria", atleast now you'll know i didnt make it all up..

jlee562 · Apr 29, 2020

whatever that original remark may or may not have been, if you'd like to take a look at the historical catalogs, you'll see that the nutria quality felt was fairly well represented:

https://www.thefedoralounge.com/threads/miller-stockman-catalogs.52929/

1on1 · Apr 29, 2020

jlee562- interesting thread about the history and cool photos, but i'm not sure what you mean by "well represented"? Just to be clear, my initial inquiry was about how common/uncommon this fedora is in todays marketplace...Yes i can post it somewhere an find out soon enough, but as i mentioned earler, i am just now looking into it as we speak.

jlee562 · Apr 29, 2020

Well represented as in Stetson made a lot of nutria quality hats.

Um, if you're just looking for someone to throw out a dollar figure that you might be able to fetch on eBay....well, I decline.

1on1 · Apr 29, 2020

Ok - fair enough, appreciate your insights.

Help with dating these two vintage fedora's anyone?

One of the Regulars

Attachments

I'll Lock Up

One of the Regulars

One of the Regulars

One of the Regulars

One of the Regulars

I'll Lock Up

One of the Regulars

I'll Lock Up

I'll Lock Up

One of the Regulars

One of the Regulars

I'll Lock Up

One of the Regulars

I'll Lock Up

One of the Regulars

Log in

Forum statistics