Thoughts from the pros regarding this Fine Creek would be appreciated

I am 6'2" and 180lb with wide shoulders, i easily fit in jackets with 18" shoulders.
If you like that jacket get it, it will most likely be ok.

 

It's in the classifieds right here:
https://www.thefedoralounge.com/threads/fine-creek-leather-hh-james-size-40.102448/

 

My concern wasn't the shoulder width, it was the p2p. Fine Creek runs small and a 20-inch p2p would be tight for a size 38 and about right for a size 36. You normally want 3-4 extra inches around the chest. You say you're 5'8, 175. Unless you have tree trunk legs and a very thin upper body, I find it hard to believe that a jacket with a 20-inch p2p would fit you.

 

My rule is if its looks to be a gamble on size then it has to be at a low enough price that I know I can pass it along without too much loss. Sounds like the right call on this one.

 

Actually a great price for this jacket. You could prob sell it on Grailed for way more with better photos.