Want to buy or sell something? Check the classifieds
  • The Fedora Lounge is supported in part by commission earning affiliate links sitewide. Please support us by using them. You may learn more here.

Lining - Harris Tweed vs Herringbone Tweed

jpk_NJ

One Too Many
Messages
1,216
Location
NJ
How does the Harris Tweed compare to Aero's Brown Herringbone Tweed? Warmer? Softer? Durability? Coat will be about 28inch long so I need something that can take abuse. Alpaca would be warm but probably wear through easily.
 

Fanch

I'll Lock Up
Messages
4,490
Location
Texas
Consider moleskin or even corduroy body shell lining and cotton drill sleeves for durability and warmth. My 28" FQHH Teamster lined with the moleskin/cotton drill served me well for cold/foul weather.
 

cordwangler

One of the Regulars
Messages
187
Location
UK
How does the Harris Tweed compare to Aero's Brown Herringbone Tweed? Warmer? Softer? Durability? Coat will be about 28inch long so I need something that can take abuse. Alpaca would be warm but probably wear through easily.

I'm not sure that current tweed is durable enough as a lining for a heavy jacket. It will abrade where it rubs against belt loops, jeans pockets, etc. I'm basing this on personal experience. I've a Harris tweed jacket six years old that's worn through on one side., probably from carrying a rucksack on one shoulder on relatively few occasions. It hasn't worn through elsewhere.

I could be wrong, and maybe Aero use a particularly hard-wearing tweed.

Moleskin, like Fanch says, might be the way to go.
 

jpk_NJ

One Too Many
Messages
1,216
Location
NJ
Definitely concerned with durability since this will be a Long Halfbelt in cordovan Steer. Will be worn in NYC Fall winter, so 30F-55F. Can anyone chime in on how Cord/Moleskin sleeve linings might work? Maybe full cord / full moleskin, or cord body and moleskin sleeves?
 

Seb Lucas

I'll Lock Up
Messages
7,562
Location
Australia
I wonder if it might be better to think about cotton drill for wear and versatility - can then wear it in warmer weather - and wear a fleece underneath when it's cold. Since it's a long half belt, you could wear a fisherman's roll neck sweater underneath if it were really cold.
 

jpk_NJ

One Too Many
Messages
1,216
Location
NJ
But NYC is just a tiny bit colder than Texas mr fanch. I have cotton drill in 3 jackets and it's just bearable. That's why I'm looking for a slightly warmer sleeve, but don't want to sweat like I'm wearing shearling. I'm also not one to layers clothes. Just a single long sleeve shirt or sweater, but not a combination.

Sleeves- go with Cord or Moleskin?

QUOTE=Fanch;1978386]Definitely cotton drill sleeves for ease of use.[/QUOTE]
 

dan_t

Practically Family
Messages
950
Location
Sydney, Australia
Wouldn't cord or moleskin in the sleeves make it difficult to get in & out of? I imagine it would catch on everything you wear (long sleeves of course).
Surely cotton drill is recommended by the manufacturer for a reason.
 

tropicalbob

My Mail is Forwarded Here
Messages
3,954
Location
miami, fl
The LHB is a jacket meant for fall and spring temperatures, not the depths of a NY winter especially if you don't want to layer. For that you'd probably want an Irvin or something of the kind. A lounge member up in Canada (can't recall his name) recently had a heavy steer jacket heavily lined in alpaca that was about as warm-looking as I've seen.
 

Forum statistics

Threads
107,396
Messages
3,036,111
Members
52,815
Latest member
Elzbthy
Top