Want to buy or sell something? Check the classifieds

H-D Cycle King Jacket Vs. Aero Indian Ranger

AeroFan_07

I'll Lock Up
Messages
4,667
Location
Iowa
I have been thinking for a while now about this comparison. I never thought I could make it materialize, as by all appearances the options to purchase one of the two jackets here was extinct. Then, it suddenly materialized, almost unexpectedly.


As has been discussed in another thread, the Vanson-sourced Cycle King jacket was a short run commissioned by the Harley Museum in Milwaukee, WI. It has a D-pocket, a full-round belt, stitched down top loops, decorative studs on the zipper pulls, #10 nickel main sipper, and #5 nickel zips on sleeves and pockets, all Vanson branded. The liner is a Woolrich Rob Roy red/black plaid. This jacket is Steerhide with a waxy finish as the photos show. The jacket listed here is a Size Large. It is not offered in numeric sizes.

DSC_0939.JPG


DSC_0961.JPG


** Background brought to you by the Mississippi River


Fit details – This is a boxy, straight-cut jacket that does not have much physical taper. The jacket may relax some as it starts to break in; it has only been worn an hour or so at this point. Also the sleeves in this model are indeed large – they almost look wide enough to install armor into them. Had this all been known, I could have considered sizing down to a Medium, however I doubt the sleeve & back length would have been sufficient going that route.

Dimensions for a Size Large:

- Shoulders – 19”/48cm

- Pit to Pit – 23.25”/59cm

- Waist – 21.5”/54.6cm

- Sleeve (Straight) 25.5”/64.8cm

- Sleeve width (3” from Shoulder)

- Back – 25.25”/64cm

To me this is surprising – I had to measure it again to be sure. How could 1.5” less Pit to Pit feel boxier to me? (Compare to IR dimensions below)

DSC_0950.JPG DSC_0955.JPG DSC_0972.JPG DSC_0973.JPG



The Aero Indian Ranger is more familiar to this forum. Mine arrived in mid April in Horween FQHH, and it has probably seen about 10 hours of wearing time at this point. It is a modified size 44, with the waist taken in a bit from normal stock width. This jacket, due to the alterations Carrie at Thurston Brothers recommended, fits me better in several ways from the Vanson – Cycle King as the fit photos show (in second post). As noted in prior posts, this jacket features:

- Rob Rob Lightweight Red/Black tartan lining.

- Mixed hardware (all #5 brass for zippers)

- Full nickel snaps with backing snap-down ability

- Front-half belt that tapers ever so slightly to the middle

- One interior pocket with no closure

Dimensions for a Size “44”

- Shoulders – 19.5”/49.5cm

- Pit to Pit – 25”63.5cm

- Waist – 21.5”/54.6cm

- Sleeve (Straight) 25.5”/64.8cm

- Back – 25.5”/64.8cm



So which one do I like better? Well, it is hard to say. They are both unique in their own special ways. I am very thankful and humbled to own both of these at the same time. I do not have the ability to have dozens of jackets of any similar caliber, so it is quite a neat experience to own these two great jackets and get them broken in over the next few years.

DSC_0958.JPG

From a fit perspective, I prefer the Aero, it’s much closer to an “ideal” fit on me and would be better with one more layer on underneath as the fit photos will show. For some reason, the Front Quarter Horse Hide on this jacket is some of the nicest I have handled; it is just glossy enough and very slick/smooth to the touch. It already is showing a bit of tea core, but I do not mean to hurry the break-in on this jacket. I actually really like it being basic black with the red and black lining and mixed hardware of bright brass and plated nickel (or plated brass in the case of the belt buckle.) interestingly the #5 brass Talon reproduction main zipper has a nice, solid feel and the chin-link style pocket pull zippers just look so very detailed.

DSC_0957.JPG

The Vanson is on the larger size for me. However, as the leather itself starts to break in, I believe it will settle down and be a very versatile, rugged jacket that has some interesting details. The #10 zipper is a plus, it is sturdy and handy to use, and looks great on this pattern. The leather itself is rather flat presently, however it is already taking shape – the waxy feel is evident and it looks like grain is beginning to pop out. I am hoping this will develop into a great jacket as time and use occur.

DSC_0949.JPG DSC_0951.JPG
 

Canuck Panda

One Too Many
Messages
1,969
Indian vs Harley, hard to decide then, still hard to decide now. Both are AWESOME (Thumbs up emoji didnt work sorry).
 
Last edited:

gtrplyr

A-List Customer
Messages
307
Location
Wisconsin
I gotta vote for the Vanson, likely because I'm lucky enough to own one. Almost impossible to find one now. If I'm not mistaken, they're made from the now discontinued X150 leather. Very cool jacket. They do run big as I originally got a Large but exchanged it for a Medium (I'm rarely a medium). I like the length of the Vanson on you better as well. I personally like jackets to cover one's belt.
 

Mysteryo

One Too Many
Messages
1,118
Location
Nantes (FR)
They both look great on you, but I have a slight preference for the Vanson in terms of shape, especially at the back. Congratulations, anyway: both jackets are top notch!
 
Top