9mm is fine with decent hollowpoints and my hipower is the most reliable pistol I own. 10mm is too long to fit in the hipower's magwell just like .45acp. FN has produced hipowers in .40 S&W, but you can't upgrade an older model. FN had to change their frame metallurgy to prevent cracking under the additional load. The slide is also bigger and heavier with an additional locking lug.
-
The Fedora Lounge is supported in part by commission earning affiliate links sitewide. Please support us by using them. You may learn more here.
Show us your Guns!
- Thread starter Undertow
- Start date
A 9mm hollow point may expand, but a .45 sure as hell won't shrink. An in depth discussion of bullets and wound ballistics is really too far off topic for the forum. That said, the Browning-designed Hi Power is probably the best 9mm pistol ever designed specifically for military use, just as the Browning-designed Model 1911 is probably the best .45 caliber pistol ever designed specifically for military use.
Until 1978 the only 9mm pistol that I carried was a Hi Power (in 1978 I replaced it with a CZ75); that said, my preferred carry was, and continues to be, a Colt Commander in .45 ACP. Like I said earlier, a 9mm hollow point may expand, but a .45 isn't going to shrink...
Until 1978 the only 9mm pistol that I carried was a Hi Power (in 1978 I replaced it with a CZ75); that said, my preferred carry was, and continues to be, a Colt Commander in .45 ACP. Like I said earlier, a 9mm hollow point may expand, but a .45 isn't going to shrink...
- Messages
- 15,563
- Location
- East Central Indiana
I'm comfortable and confident with the .45 acp after carrying and shooting one for years. I also prefer the pushing type recoil and boom over the more harsh jerk and echoing crack of the .357. The 9mm has mild wrist impact with more of a pop pop...that has always left me a little underwhelmed..but that's probably because I've shot them less often than some others. Recoil has never really bothered me much with any weapon...but the crack of a .357 with unprotected ears can have very harsh after effects..as well as some other more violent calibers. I'm with you Rathdown..the 45acp is hard to beat for personal protection IMO,too.
HD
HD
Kirk H.
One Too Many
- Messages
- 1,196
- Location
- Charlotte NC
I could hear the opening theme song as soon as I saw this.
Me too!!! Also I can see Fish getting up and heading for the "can" every few minutes. Maybe that is why he preferred a shoulder rig to a belt holster
LoveMyHats2
I’ll Lock Up.
- Messages
- 5,196
- Location
- Michigan
It may be a police application of a holster on his pants, may have been too hard for him to keep up? lol!Me too!!! Also I can see Fish getting up and heading for the "can" every few minutes. Maybe that is why he preferred a shoulder rig to a belt holster
There are so many very nice shoulder holsters made, where to start???
My Wife has a holster that has the steel inside the "clip" of the holster to hold the weapon in place until you desire to pull it out, it seems to work for her just fine. If she is not carrying the weapon in the holster, she has a leather purse made by Galco, that it fits in about right.
Just looking at all the leather goodies that are on the market for shoulder rigs does not help making a choice very easy.
I could hear the opening theme song as soon as I saw this.
Greatest guitar riff ever.
Roving_Bohemian
One of the Regulars
- Messages
- 250
While I agree that a .45 is more effective, the effects of a 9mm through a vital are quite damaging, and for some of us 9mm is more available (in Europe you can barely FIND .45acp) and more cost effective... Still, as Rathdown said, "a .45 sure as hell won't shrink."
I really like shoulder holsters both for the look and feel... I'm personally (I have no problem with others carrying this way, I just don't have the experience to make me comfortable with it) not comfortable [yet] carrying horizontal, so would likely carry in any of these models
something like this for the 1911s...
(I think another "Lounger" posted that pic somewhere?)
I sure as heck wouldn't feel comfortable using one of these
GreatWhiteHunter
Familiar Face
- Messages
- 53
"However..the Browning Hi-Power just feels so good in my hand..and for me..is always a joy to shoot."
Better live with an ugly one than to die with a pretty one . . . . That goes for guns too! I'll take the 45!
Better live with an ugly one than to die with a pretty one . . . . That goes for guns too! I'll take the 45!
Kirk H.
One Too Many
- Messages
- 1,196
- Location
- Charlotte NC
I got this off the Yahoo Broomhandle group, I thought some of you might get a kick out of it!
Now that is a holster and a mustache too.
Renault
One Too Many
- Messages
- 1,688
- Location
- Wilbarger creek bottom
I got this off the Yahoo Broomhandle group, I thought some of you might get a kick out of it!
Thanks Stearman, I've been lookin' for a photo of Great Grandpa Renault! LOL
As soon as I can figger out how to take a decent photo , I'll post a pic of the newest piece of nickel plated perfection I recently "acquired".........
It is a S&W......Renault
Michaelshane
One Too Many
- Messages
- 1,928
- Location
- Land of Enchantment
I got this off the Yahoo Broomhandle group, I thought some of you might get a kick out of it!
Sigh. That's one I still want. Now that I have the P38, the broomhandle Mauser is the other gun I've always wanted.
Probably the last man alive packing a war-time, 7.65mm, FEG. I love old school cool...
Michaelshane
One Too Many
- Messages
- 1,928
- Location
- Land of Enchantment
I'm surprised anyone knows what it is....!
Oldsarge
One Too Many
- Messages
- 1,440
- Location
- On the banks of the Wilamette
Hey, in cyberspace there's someone who knows what just about everything is!
Renault
One Too Many
- Messages
- 1,688
- Location
- Wilbarger creek bottom
Yeah, and sold my C96 to a friend....... Wifey has an FEG in 9mm Kurz !!! Came in the shop about 4 months ago with an extra mag. Being that she collects small autos she had to have it! It is extremely clean. (Ssssshhh!!! I've got a 1914 Mauser Pocket auto secreted on my workbench for her!!!! )....... Someday I suppose I should post a pic of all her "pocket autos" here on the forum.....
Here's the latest addition. I decided to go ahead a snap a pic of her on my workbench today. She is lovely!!!!
New Smith &Wesson Herritage series Model of 1950 (model 22) in .45 ACP. Glad still have about 8 boxes of "auto rim" stashed! Personally I think this is the perfect revolver!!!! Can't wait to slap a polished aluminum "Tyler-T" on her!
Renault
)....... Someday I suppose I should post a pic of all her "pocket autos" here on the forum.....Here's the latest addition. I decided to go ahead a snap a pic of her on my workbench today. She is lovely!!!!
New Smith &Wesson Herritage series Model of 1950 (model 22) in .45 ACP. Glad still have about 8 boxes of "auto rim" stashed! Personally I think this is the perfect revolver!!!! Can't wait to slap a polished aluminum "Tyler-T" on her!
Renault
Kirk H.
One Too Many
- Messages
- 1,196
- Location
- Charlotte NC
Yeah, and sold my C96 to a friend....... Wifey has an FEG in 9mm Kurz !!! Came in the shop about 4 months ago with an extra mag. Being that she collects small autos she had to have it! It is extremely clean. (Ssssshhh!!! I've got a 1914 Mauser Pocket auto secreted on my workbench for her!!!!
Here's the latest addition. I decided to go ahead a snap a pic of her on my workbench today. She is lovely!!!!
New Smith &Wesson Herritage series Model of 1950 (model 22) in .45 ACP. Glad still have about 8 boxes of "auto rim" stashed! Personally I think this is the perfect revolver!!!! Can't wait to slap a polished aluminum "Tyler-T" on her!
Renault
That is beautiful!!! Let us know how it shoots. Are you still thinking about rechambering it for 45 LC?
