Interesting. There's never been a lack of info here and that includes negative experiences/outcomes. The differnce as I see it is the way it's delivered. We've all read posts of new jackets that were less than perfect, but the tone and the apparent intent was nothing more than to be informative, learn, and move on. Now, we need to do this? Really? Is it for the "good of the forum" that some propose this? Because I've never seen the need for it as opinions and outcomes have been posted for years. Are we now going to get the errant p*ssed off GW client that didn't get a great fit? Does that really need it's own thread? We've seen a Good Wear Ventura posted up that apparently shrunk from rain. We see JeffM still waiting on a BK. Two newer guys got hosed up Alexander jackets. It's here for all to see with no malice as are many others from Alexander, Bill Kelso, LW, etc. If this is indeed deemed a necessity, make I generic. And start populating it with complaints. Or, leave it as is and we'll open others that are sure to grow quite large quite soon. I'd rather the former, but I'm not a host.