Feltfan:
While I have professed to not be that interested in the history of the different welts, I will say that your post is very interesting. I don’t know whether Cavanagh edges being stitched is a surprise to others, but it was certainly a surprise to me.
Do you still have the hat...
I should have been clearer - I don’t care about why or when edge treatments came into being. I am much more interested in people’s thoughts on the on the aesthetic merits or demerits of the different edge treatments.
Also, I would appreciate it if someone could give a very specific...
I have posted this question, in a slightly modified form elsewhere, but I think it belongs here as well.
I have come across some posts indicating that the origin of many edge treatments such as self welting or ribbon binding results from a decline in felt quality or thickness. The edge...
JP: The bow on your Panama looks to be not only from a solid Ribbon, but also gray, rather than the striped blue of the main ribbon. Is that correct? How do you like that? I have to say that while I like the block, I don’t think I like the look of the bow very much. I would have preferred...
Please don’t mention Montecristis blocked by Art. It drives me insane. I really wanted him to do my Panama Bob hat, but he was moving and I missed the boat by a little bit. I have been kicking myself ever since. Ouch!!! I did it again.
A Montecristi from PB
The Montecristi that I got from PB and wrote about when I first joined the forum was ready and I picked it up from the hat shop/blocker yesterday. I hope to take and post some pics of it over the next few days. That, and the cheaper Montecrisiti I got from PB, is likely...
I have also had difficulty getting e-mail responses from Optimo, although I am certain they have been received. Fortunately, I have been beta testing this new service to reach Optimo, which so far has worked pretty well. Unlike the web, data is streamed in complete bursts rather than packets...
Anyone ever heard of Dobbs’ Hankachif Felt? That is not a typo - it is spelled “Hankachif�. I have it on a 1.75 inch brim hat. Nothing spectacular, but a very nice vintage felt. It is not particularly lightweight as you would expect from the name, but possibly meant to compete with...
The title of this thread has always puzzled me. If I were to pull a hat through the RIGHT end of a cow, how much better off would I be? And which is the right end to pull a hat through?
I have one of Panama Bob’s low-priced Montecristi’s. It is a great hat for the money, and a good summer hat alternative to what you are looking at (mine was cheaper, but I think he sells across a pretty wide range of prices). On the other hand, they are not at all like a Milan Straw hat in...
Wait a second . . . are you telling me to wear it and form my own opinion? If I could do that, why would I be here? Just kidding of course. Your advice is about as sound as it comes. Of course, if I took good advice, I wouldn’t be dopey, would I?
My real hang-up with the hat is the...
Does anyone have any idea when this hat dates from?
The hat is actually a light grayish tan, not gray. The band is not pleated as it might appear.
It has three colors: dark brown, with three thin light tan stripes. Below the stripes there is a darker tan stripe that is faded to look like...
I re-read the description again, and it is misleading. I don't think it was intentional. In any event, as I posted on another thread, I have been the beneficiary of a hat being much better than described on e-bay. I will take this one as ______ happens and not get too upset about it. The...
So this turned out to be less exciting than I thought. The auction description was accurate, but I didn’t read carefully enough. The box is a Stetson - very high quality heavy cardboard with a leather strap. The hat though, is not a 7x Beaver Stetson Open Road. It is a Shudde Bros. house...
UPDATE
After giving me the run-around for weeks, the hat guy I was using called me on Monday to tell me he had finished the blocking and I could come in and bring him the sweat and choose a ribbon. I went by today. As you can imagine, I had been pretty annoyed at the more than month-long...
I just received the package from this auction. The hat was in as good condition as described. Perfect, albeit a bit dusty. What the seller didn’t say or photograph was that this was a Knox Twenty with a Custom Edge (i.e. self-felted like a Cavanaugh edge)...
Selv-Edge
Thanks again, JP. I have a Selv-edge 3X that looks to be folded over and then stitched down. The edge of the fold seems to be a sharp cut edge rather than the smooth joint you would expect if it were felted in. The stitching though is so fine and widely spaced as to be barely...
This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.