Want to buy or sell something? Check the classifieds
  • The Fedora Lounge is supported in part by commission earning affiliate links sitewide. Please support us by using them. You may learn more here.

1920s pinches (Prohibition)

KingTigerII

New in Town
Messages
32
Location
Bowling Green, OH United States
You make good points about the difficulty of finding a size proper to you. Frankly, even if you did manage to find a 20's style hat in a 7 3/4 on ebay, the price would likely be somewhere in the $400 range due to the fact that people nowadays tend to have larger heads and there's a great demand for really vintage hats. :eusa_doh: You're better off contacting someone like Art Fawcett or Tumwater Hat Co. It will be expensive (somewhere in the $300 range), but you'll be getting EXACTLY what you want in EXACTLY your size and the hat will last a life time. I'm not as much of an authority as many of the people here, but I've handled and worn hats from some of the best craftsmen in the business and these beauties are worth the expensive price tag. -M

*drools at that thought*

Bookmarked. I will be ordering a custom Fedora, hands-down, from one of those two. Light Grey, with a Dark Graphite Ribbon (if they have it!). Tumwater's prices and product look too darn good to pass up. Not to mention with either company - the hats are made in the USA (Which makes me feel more vintage ;0) )

1920's Pinches here I come :D

Thanks Mulceber!!!!!!!
 

jlee562

I'll Lock Up
Messages
5,055
Location
San Francisco, CA
*drools at that thought*

Bookmarked. I will be ordering a custom Fedora, hands-down, from one of those two. Light Grey, with a Dark Graphite Ribbon (if they have it!). Tumwater's prices and product look too darn good to pass up. Not to mention with either company - the hats are made in the USA (Which makes me feel more vintage ;0) )

1920's Pinches here I come :D

Thanks Mulceber!!!!!!!

I'd also recommend checking out Black Sheep Hat Works, and The Penman Hat Co., both fine custom hat makers who I can vouch for personally.
 

Mulceber

Practically Family
Messages
753
Location
Ann Arbor, Michigan
Agreed - I just checked out BSHW's website recently and they've definitely got some nice ones. And they're improving, to boot. And of course Penman's always done good work. Oh and we can't forget Optimo. The advantage with Optimo is you're getting one of the best hats in the world from an honest-to-goodness hat store in Chicago. The downside is 1) the price, which is more than double what Tumwater charges and 2) having looked at Optimo's hats and owned a couple, I find that most of their hat blocks are more of the 40's-50's variety, meaning that their hats tend to be a bit more tapered than the 20's styles you're looking for. Graham does wonderful work though and he could probably make a less tapered hat if you wanted.


Thanks Mulceber!!!!!!!

No problem :) - also, one word of advice: when ordering from any of these fine gents, email them some pictures of yourself and a description of your build. It'll help them advise you on finding a hat that is not just accurate to the 20's, but also suits your build and face shape. -M
 
Last edited:

Woodfluter

Practically Family
Messages
784
Location
Georgia
I think both Alan F and Monbal256 make very good points. To that I'd add:

(1) I have and like four Akubra Feds. If you want a side dent, I'd suggest steam. Not cooking your hat, just a light application to render it supple. Some favor soaking and I used to go that route way back, but honestly can't see anything to recommend about that. Steam will do the same faster and with less drying time! Don't over-apply heat, just a few seconds per area will suffice.

(2) Vintage hats seem a different story to me. I'm old enough (and have peculiar memory qualities) to vividly recall handling gentlemen's hats in the 1950s, while a little kid, and those memories match my better vintage hats plus what I see in old movies. Those weren't over a few years old at the time, so I don't think it can all be explained by aging of the felt.

As a random example, I have a brown narrow-ribbon Dobbs at hand...it has front pinch right now but if I want side dents, I can do that instantly and there's no visible remnant of front pinch showing. If I leave it that way a few days it will want to return to that shape, a bit, but otherwise it's completely flexible. They just don't make 'em that way anymore as far as I've seen. No steam required, no hassle, just shape it as you like it. Quite amazing if you've only seen modern hats.

The Prohibition series was mesmerizing and I did spend a lot of time studying (and wishing I could freeze frames) all the clothing and hats in those photographs. Burns always does a great job.

- Bill
 
Messages
17,251
Location
Maryland
Prohibition but not hat related. I have a copy this photo hanging in my house.

"Breakfast in the Free State!, 1927 H.L. Mencken"

6134652023_7b8e0ee365_o.jpg
 
Last edited:

The Wiser Hatter

I'll Lock Up
Messages
4,765
Location
Louisville, Ky
Hat's for Ken Burn's Prohibition

I have been slowly watching this new Ken Burn's documentary. An if you love hats you should watch it. Also if you love Boardwalk Empire you should really watch.:)

Here are some screen shots of the hat's
web.jpg


Love these caps!

web.jpg



web.jpg



web.jpg


web.jpg


web.jpg


web.jpg


web.jpg


will be watching more good shots.:)
 

Esme

One of the Regulars
Messages
169
Location
Eugene, Oregon
Wait, did you say those were screen shots or mug shots? LOL
My husband would love this show. Must have a look for it.
 
Messages
15,241
Location
Somewhere south of crazy
Great shots, Ed, thanks for posting those. I intend to get the set of videos from Amazon, I love Ken Burns'
stuff.

By the way, the closeup shot of the guy with the dark narrow brim upturned hat is Johnny Torio, one of Al Capone's predecessors. He is one of the few gangsters to die of "natural causes".
 
Last edited:

Tomasso

Incurably Addicted
Messages
13,719
Location
USA
Johnny Torio, one of Al Capone's predecessors. He is one of the few gangsters to die of " natural causes ".
Sure, because he decided to retire after getting all shot up and then doing a stretch in the pen. Would Capone's death be classified as 'natural causes'?
 

1961MJS

My Mail is Forwarded Here
Messages
3,363
Location
Norman Oklahoma
Hi

I just finished a new book on Bonnie and Clyde. Clyde wore his hats in a VERY stylish manner. Couldn't rob a lemonade stand successfully, but he could sure drive the getaway car.

Clyde wasn't exactly huge, but his hat is in the picture below:
http://www.enidbuzz.com/bonnie-clyde/

I also like Ted Hinton's Hollywood brim in the picture at the bottom of this page:
http://www.censusdiggins.com/bonnie_and_clyde_2.html

Different bunch, same era. I hope it wasn't wrong to hop on here.
 

The Wiser Hatter

I'll Lock Up
Messages
4,765
Location
Louisville, Ky
Great shots, Ed, thanks for posting those. I intend to get the set of videos from Amazon, I love Ken Burns'
stuff.

By the way, the closeup shot of the guy with the dark narrow brim upturned hat is Johnny Torio, one of Al Capone's predecessors. He is one of the few gangsters to die of "natural causes".

Yes, that is Johnny Torio Love seeing the real faces of the Boardwalk Empire.:)
 
Messages
15,241
Location
Somewhere south of crazy
Hi

I just finished a new book on Bonnie and Clyde. Clyde wore his hats in a VERY stylish manner. Couldn't rob a lemonade stand successfully, but he could sure drive the getaway car.

Clyde wasn't exactly huge, but his hat is in the picture below:
http://www.enidbuzz.com/bonnie-clyde/

I also like Ted Hinton's Hollywood brim in the picture at the bottom of this page:
http://www.censusdiggins.com/bonnie_and_clyde_2.html

Different bunch, same era. I hope it wasn't wrong to hop on here.

"Go Down Together"? Great book. They really weren't very successful bandits, but interesting characters. I love the pic of the "laws" in their hats.
 

Forum statistics

Threads
107,314
Messages
3,033,789
Members
52,770
Latest member
green_entrails
Top