Want to buy or sell something? Check the classifieds
  • The Fedora Lounge is supported in part by commission earning affiliate links sitewide. Please support us by using them. You may learn more here.

Optimo south side mobsters

Messages
18,946
Location
Central California
I recently bought a 7 ½ Optimo. Doc @NewJack reached out and offered a trade. This 7 ⅝ was my end of it:

IMG_8394.jpeg
IMG_8388.jpeg
IMG_8392.jpeg
IMG_8395.jpeg
IMG_8396.jpeg
IMG_8397.jpeg
IMG_8398.jpeg
IMG_8399.jpeg
IMG_8400.jpeg
IMG_8401.jpeg


It’s in great condition, but it’s half to a whole size too small for me. The felt on the 7 ½ blue-gray was more to my liking with a softer hand.

I’ve now owned around seven Optimos now. They are all well-made hats. The styling, including the tapered crowns and modest crown heights, just don’t work for me. The felt has been good or better, but I’ve never found it to be exceptional.
 
Last edited:

Rmccamey

I'll Lock Up
Messages
5,667
Location
Central Texas
I've never owned an Optimo but I did visit the store several years ago. As you state, their fedoras seem to lean toward Borsalino with the taper and shorter crown, so they have never been high on my Get List. The pictures always look very nice.

I’ve now owned around seven Optimos now. They are all well-made hats. The styling, including the tapered crowns and modest crown heights, just don’t work for me. The felt has been good or better, but I’ve never found it to be exceptional.
 

Mighty44

One Too Many
Messages
1,747
I recently bought a 7 ½ Optimo. Doc @NewJack reached out and offered a trade. This 7 ⅝ was my end of it:

View attachment 577746 View attachment 577747 View attachment 577748 View attachment 577749 View attachment 577750 View attachment 577751 View attachment 577752 View attachment 577753 View attachment 577754 View attachment 577755

It’s in great condition, but it’s half to a whole size too small for me. The felt on the 7 ½ blue-gray was more to my liking with a softer hand.

I’ve now owned around seven Optimos now. They are all well-made hats. The styling, including the tapered crowns and modest crown heights, just don’t work for me. The felt has been good or better, but I’ve never found it to be exceptional.
Agreed—the proportions on this are way off for my taste.
 
Messages
18,946
Location
Central California
Agreed—the proportions on this are way off for my taste.


To be fair, part of what makes the proportions seem off is the wider than typical brim, something I like. I wish it had a taller crown; although, at 5 ½” open it’s not a particularly low crown.

If the hat had been blocked on a minimally tapered block (52 or similar) with a height of around six inches I’d like the hat much more. Even then, I would never be able to justify the cost of one new. It’s no doubt a well-made hat, but a large part of what you are buying is the name.


IMG_8402.jpeg
 

Mighty44

One Too Many
Messages
1,747
To be fair, part of what makes the proportions seem off is the wider than typical brim, something I like. I wish it had a taller crown; although, at 5 ½” open it’s not a particularly low crown.

If the hat had been blocked on a minimally tapered block (52 or similar) with a height of around six inches I’d like the hat much more. Even then, I would never be able to justify the cost of one new. It’s no doubt a well-made hat, but a large part of what you are buying is the name.

To be fair, part of what makes the proportions seem off is the wider than typical brim, something I like. I wish it had a taller crown; although, at 5 ½” open it’s not a particularly low crown.

If the hat had been blocked on a minimally tapered block (52 or similar) with a height of around six inches I’d like the hat much more. Even then, I would never be able to justify the cost of one new. It’s no doubt a well-made hat, but a large part of what you are buying is the name.


View attachment 577947
The brim does accent. Less taper would help a lot. Does look nice otherwise. A brown sweat would class it up a bit, too.
 
Messages
18,946
Location
Central California
I've never owned an Optimo but I did visit the store several years ago. As you state, their fedoras seem to lean toward Borsalino with the taper and shorter crown, so they have never been high on my Get List. The pictures always look very nice.


I’ve read your similar comments before. Many Borsalinos have minimally tapered crowns of “regular” height. I’ve had different experiences with vintage Borsalinos. To be sure, they made a huge variety of hats and it all aren’t my liking (e.g., the Agusta line), but as someone who likes boxy tall crowns I can say Borsalino made some of my favorite hats!
 

Mighty44

One Too Many
Messages
1,747
I’ve read your similar comments before. Many Borsalinos have minimally tapered crowns of “regular” height. I’ve had different experiences with vintage Borsalinos. To be sure, they made a huge variety of hats and it all aren’t my liking (e.g., the Agusta line), but as someone who likes boxy tall crowns I can say Borsalino made some of my favorite hats!
Agreed—I’ve got some terrific vintage borsas that are shaped very much like vintage American hats.
 

Altiori

One of the Regulars
Messages
107
Location
Savannah, GA
A happy day!
Received this afternoon my custom open crown in nicotine from the craftspeople at Optimo.
I post several photos in attempt to do justice to this beauty.

I am blessed to have purchased three Optimo hats over the past 8 years. The craftsmanship is impeccable, the felt is of the highest quality, and the customer service is thoughtful, engaging, personal and professional. I worked with Graham personally on this. It was my pleasure.

One photo is of all three Optimo’s: the Mondo, the new Nicotine, and the Montecristi Panama. These will get me through the year.

Cheers to all.

M enjoying a Manhattan preprandial while celebrating this Chicago marvel.
IMG_5099.jpeg
IMG_5098.jpeg
IMG_5097.jpeg
IMG_5096.jpeg
IMG_5093.jpeg
IMG_5095.jpeg
 

Rmccamey

I'll Lock Up
Messages
5,667
Location
Central Texas
Very nice. Thanks for sharing.

A happy day!
Received this afternoon my custom open crown in nicotine from the craftspeople at Optimo.
I post several photos in attempt to do justice to this beauty.

I am blessed to have purchased three Optimo hats over the past 8 years. The craftsmanship is impeccable, the felt is of the highest quality, and the customer service is thoughtful, engaging, personal and professional. I worked with Graham personally on this. It was my pleasure.

One photo is of all three Optimo’s: the Mondo, the new Nicotine, and the Montecristi Panama. These will get me through the year.

Cheers to all.

M enjoying a Manhattan preprandial while celebrating this Chicago marvel.
 

doberdadinmd

Familiar Face
Messages
97
Location
Eastern North Carolina
A happy day!
Received this afternoon my custom open crown in nicotine from the craftspeople at Optimo.
I post several photos in attempt to do justice to this beauty.

I am blessed to have purchased three Optimo hats over the past 8 years. The craftsmanship is impeccable, the felt is of the highest quality, and the customer service is thoughtful, engaging, personal and professional. I worked with Graham personally on this. It was my pleasure.

One photo is of all three Optimo’s: the Mondo, the new Nicotine, and the Montecristi Panama. These will get me through the year.

Cheers to all.

M enjoying a Manhattan preprandial while celebrating this Chicago marvel. View attachment 586356 View attachment 586357 View attachment 586358 View attachment 586359 View attachment 586360 View attachment 586361
Love the color on that Mundo!
 

Altiori

One of the Regulars
Messages
107
Location
Savannah, GA
Was just up in Baltimore and got complimented on my hat and he asked if it was a Stetson, I said no, asked if it was a Dobbs, I said no. At this point I told him it was an Optimo and he replied that he literally had been looking at the Optimo website a few hours earlier! It was a treat to hand over the hat so he could take a closer look.
Great story. Optimo makes an excellent hat indeed.
I’m still playing around with the bash on my new open crown. Great fun.
 

Hats Matter

One of the Regulars
Messages
210
Location
Oakland CA
And now for something completely different...........

As I have written in this thread in years past, I have a fairly substantial number of Optimo Fedoras....19 to be precise. In the past two years or so I had a severe medical problem which resulted in a large loss of weight. The Fedoras I have are all 63 cm. and no longer fit my shrunken head. Rather than discard the Fedoras I contacted Graham and asked then if they could resize and refurbish them to 62 cm (my new head measurement. We experiment with 2 hats and they were returned to me and fit my head correctly and were nicely refurbished. I sent him 6 more hats for work and they were returned to my satisfaction. As a result I sent him the remaining 11 hats for refit and refurbishment. When there are returned I will as Graham if he can also do something with my straw hats.
 

doberdadinmd

Familiar Face
Messages
97
Location
Eastern North Carolina
And now for something completely different...........

As I have written in this thread in years past, I have a fairly substantial number of Optimo Fedoras....19 to be precise. In the past two years or so I had a severe medical problem which resulted in a large loss of weight. The Fedoras I have are all 63 cm. and no longer fit my shrunken head. Rather than discard the Fedoras I contacted Graham and asked then if they could resize and refurbish them to 62 cm (my new head measurement. We experiment with 2 hats and they were returned to me and fit my head correctly and were nicely refurbished. I sent him 6 more hats for work and they were returned to my satisfaction. As a result I sent him the remaining 11 hats for refit and refurbishment. When there are returned I will as Graham if he can also do something with my straw hats.
As someone who just recently worked with Graham on resizing two of mine I can concur with the results (though the Mundo took two tries). My wife would have a fit if I had 19!!
 

Forum statistics

Threads
107,316
Messages
3,033,912
Members
52,770
Latest member
green_entrails
Top