Want to buy or sell something? Check the classifieds
  • The Fedora Lounge is supported in part by commission earning affiliate links sitewide. Please support us by using them. You may learn more here.

PBS American Experience - The Bombing of Germany

Corky

Practically Family
Messages
507
Location
West Los Angeles
This was on PBS on Monday night. Look for it it on a repeat or it can be viewed on-line.

bombing_banner.jpg


...Author Don Miller described the raid as the crossing of "a moral threshold. And that moral threshold is, we will not deliberately bomb civilians… once we crossed the moral divide in Berlin, it made everything else, including the atomic bomb, a little bit easier."...

PBS: American Experience: The Bombing of Germany

On September 1, 1939 — the first day of World War II in Europe — President Franklin D. Roosevelt appealed to the warring nations to "under no circumstances undertake the bombardment from the air of civilian populations." Just six years later, British and American Allied forces would carry out a bombing campaign of unprecedented might over Germany's cities, claiming the lives of nearly half a million civilians. The Bombing of Germany examines the defining moments of the offensive that led the U.S. across a moral divide.

In the summer of 1942, the United States 8th Air Force saw its first action in the war when it bombed an occupied railroad yard in France. In broad daylight, the American B-17 "Flying Fortresses" successfully destroyed the military targets and avoided civilian populations. The rail yard was severely damaged and the bombers all returned safely, confirming the Americans' belief that airpower had revolutionized modern warfare and that civilian casualties could be avoided through precision daytime bombing.

The British, too, had once focused exclusively on military targets but abandoned that policy after Germany's bombing of London in the fall of 1940 resulted in thousands of civilian deaths. In July of 1943 the British Royal Air Force targeted Hamburg, an industrial city of nearly two million people. Flying under the cover of darkness and dropping thousands of tons of high explosive bombs and incendiaries upon the population below, the RAF sought to break the will of the German people to fight. The assaults destroyed nearly 60% of the city, killed an estimated 50,000 civilians, and left nearly a million people homeless.

American airmen participated in the raids on Hamburg by targeting military sites. Flying in daylight to improve accuracy and reduce civilian losses, the Americans did the best they could to hit a shipyard and an engine factory despite visibility heavily degraded by smoke from the RAF's fires. In October, the Americans' faith in the daylight bombing strategy began to waiver after several air assaults deep into German territory resulted in the loss of more than 200 bombers and hundreds of American airmen.

Towards the end of 1943 the Allied forces intensified their efforts, bombing the German capital of Berlin heavily. The addition of agile, long-range fighters to the American forces — the P-51 Mustangs — would eventually transform America's bombing strategy; now, under the escort of well-armed fighter planes, American bombers once again flew deep into enemy territory. Despite the near destruction of several cities, Germany's will to fight proved relentless as the Luftwaffe introduced even more powerful anti-aircraft rockets, as well as the world's first jet fighter, the Messerchmitt 262.

In February of 1945, under great pressure to bring the European war to an end, the American commanders finally agreed to bombard Berlin — foregoing the strategy of targeting only military sites. Home to nearly four million civilians, Berlin was nearly entirely destroyed. Author Don Miller described the raid as the crossing of "a moral threshold. And that moral threshold is, we will not deliberately bomb civilians… once we crossed the moral divide in Berlin, it made everything else, including the atomic bomb, a little bit easier."

From International Emmy Award and Peabody Award-winning producer Zvi Dor-Ner (Israel's Next War, House of Saud) comes The Bombing of Germany, a one-hour film that examines the defining moments of the U.S. bombing campaign. Weaving together veteran and historian interviews with archival footage of the bombing and its aftermath, The Bombing of Germany is a haunting reminder of the moral dilemma imposed by war's strategic imperatives.
 

Brummagem Joe

Familiar Face
Messages
78
Location
CT, USA
The problem for the British after surviving the battle of Britain was that the only way they had of taking the war to Germany was by a strategic bombing campaign that was quite openly directed against the civilian population although the euphemism was "de-housing." At the time no one bothered very much about the morality of it since German warmaking was generally heinous and they had in any case provided plenty of moral cover with their earlier bombing of Warsaw and Rotterdam. The men of both the RAF and 8th airforce who conducted the campaign were singularly brave and dedicated, casualty rates were amongst the worst on the western allied side. In the wider sense it's hard to get wound up about the moral side when you recognize that at the end of the day Nazi Germany was actually defeated principally by an equally monstrous tyranny in the Soviet Union.
 

Dixon Cannon

My Mail is Forwarded Here
Messages
3,157
Location
Sonoran Desert Hideaway
I watched this and I have a discrepancy I'd like to bring to light.

In the final segments of the program, the narrator seems to indicate that the first daylight raids on Berlin were on 03 February, 1944.

My understanding is that the first 8th USAAF raid was actually on 06 March, 1944. According to the book, Target Berlin - Mission 250: 6 March 1944
by Jeffrey Ethell and Alfred Price, "On Monday 6 March 1944 the US 8th Air Force for the first time mounted a full-scale daylight attack on Berlin, capital of the Third Reich."

Does anyone have any input on this subject? Did I misunderstand the narrator?

-dixon cannon
 

Phantomfixer

Practically Family
Messages
819
Location
Mid East coast USA
From what I remember (but not the dates) The first daylight raid on Berlin Germany was in February. The weather was bad and the fighter escort was missed and the main bomber force went on to tagerts of oppurtunity. A small force of B-17s (again I would have to go back and research which group) went on to Berlin unopposed and bombed visually. But this strike was not recorded as the first official strike as it was recalled. I will check my books tonight and post dates and groups.
JZ
 

Phantomfixer

Practically Family
Messages
819
Location
Mid East coast USA
Berlin or Big B

Okay, I just reread Airwar by Edward Jablonski. I was mistaken on a few accounts. The date was March 3rd. A bombing mission was scheduled for Berlin. The mission was recalled due to weather. 29 B-17s from the 95th and 100th, escorted by the 4th FG bombed Berlin. The force was met by 30-35 German fighters. Five B-17s were lost, 4 from the 95th and one from the 100th. The mission from the previous post was before Operation Big Week and the targets were in the vicinity of Berlin (about 90 miles). March 6th was the first successful full scale attack on Big B.
 

Forum statistics

Threads
107,287
Messages
3,033,050
Members
52,748
Latest member
R_P_Meldner
Top